Hana Kimi Japan (GMA 7) versus Hana Kimi Taiwan (ABS-CBN)

trulalu, trulalu, trulalu!

Taiwanese version is better because the lead male actor is more good-looking than the Japanese version. ABS-CBN is better at dubbing compared to GMA.

That’s the truth! Gma knows that. Pero syempre walang laban ang ABS CBN sa ratings kasi manipulated na ng GMA ang ratings. Alam na syempre natin kung sino ang magrerate. Ikaw ba naman ang mabigyan ng mega sardines at 500 pesos. Mahirap na ang buhay ngayon, aba!

Di naman kinagat ng publico ang sardinas issue na yan dahil d naman proven yan. Iilan lang ang napaniwala. Matuto nalang sana tumanggap ng pagkalo ang ABS para di mawala respeto sa kanila. Tulad sa shows na ito , eh di hayaan nalang manuod ang mga tao kung anu ang gusto nila, .

hmm yep no offense guys pero for me mas maganda mag dubb ang abs un lng po kau n humusga ^^

@chibambi

e ano ngaun kung cna bentong at pokwang? …
baka ikaw kelangan mag-isip…

@chibambi: ikaw the best dito?
halatang wala kang ibang pinanonood kungdi mga programa ng ch7 kaya WAY BELOW ANG STANDARD MO!
basta dubbing, ABS-CBN is the best! NO DOUBT ABOUT IT! anime, telenovelas etc.
ikaw ang mag isip. palibhasa puro sardinas lang bumubuhay sa yo.

mas gugustuhin ko pang manood ng ASAP kesa SOP.
ni di kilala mga kumakanta dun maliban sa mga datihan na (janno, ogie, regine, JAYA(?)).
magtanong ako sa may isip?
buti pinaalala mong wag akong magtanong sa yo KASI WALA KANG ISIP!

@ chibambi
hahaha… kawawa ka naman… ang baba ng taste mo..
heller! kasalanan bang ipalabas sa tv ang mga sikat? hahaha.. omg… are u even thinking?
well… think again…
so parang inami mo na rin na di marunong magpasikat ang kanguso… hahaha…
and.. di na nga sikat ung mga kumakanta sa inyong perya.. mga walang rehearsal pa ung iba.. kaya nawawala sa notes.. hahaha… si regine lang talaga ang gusto ko sa sop.. un lang..

napaka-pathetic talaga ng sop.. pangit ng lights, so dry ang camera… nagsisisikan sa liit ng stage. haha..SO DRY talaga…

Ang gulo! naglabas ng Meteor Garden ang ABS-CBN noon kumuha ng 5566 ang GMA. Tapos kinuha ang Hana yori Dango. Di pa nakuntento pinalabas pa nila ng Meteor Garden pati na ung sequel. Sobrang hayuk talaga sa ratings ang GMA. Talagang kinuha pa ang MG para maka-simut ng RATINGS! Kul;ang na lang pati Mara Clara gawan nila ng version eh! Walang patawad ang GMA pati mga CARTOONS na pinalabas na sa ABS-CBN na kinalakihan na naten eh kinuha pa! alam nyo kung bakit? Dahil HAYUK sa RATINGS! Tapos ngayon nalaman nilang maglalabas ang DOS ng HANA KIMI kumuha din sila nun IBANG VERSION nga lang… Haay… GMA SUCKS!

As in SOBRA! SUGAPA sa RATINGS… bwahaha s inyo na ratings wala namang sense ang mga palabas nyo!!

….hay wa ako ma say….. trulalu naman na lahat pinalabas ng GMA after ipalapas sa ABS ung metteor garden 1 and 2…the first ever asian TV series na naipalabas sa Phil….pero i think mas maganda and pagka dub sa ABS…and now and hana kimi nanaman,,, if i were u panoorin nyo n lng sa crunchyroll.com…. ung dalawang version… ok… world peace….

@ chibambi

di mo makita ang sense kasi wala ka ring sense.. close-minded…

Actually, kung hindi ibabase sa kung saan galing yung story ng Hana Kimi (Jap Manga), mas orig yung Hana Kimi ng Taiwan kasi mas nauna siyang pinalabas. November 2006. Yung Jap version kasi July 2007. Pero parang mas gusto ko yung Taiwanese version.

ang totoo lamang na ang gma at ang ginagawa ng dos ngayon ay playing catch up nalang
ang serye nila palagi ikli nalang kasi hanap ng papatok sa masa .. example magingsino kaman 2 weeks nalang ito tigok na…sa dami ng powerhouse cast di na kaya ang gastos kayat kailangan ng mawala….tong ipapalit na taiwanese serye ay low cost na sana pumatok.. NOte.. di sa timeslot ha.

pero

die hard dos fans lang manunuod nito…

mas marami gma viewers ang nood sa jap version …

kayat kyo dos fans support your own kasi unti nalang kayo… tapos silip pa kayo sa 7 hayyy edi dag dag pa viewers ng 7 nyan…

TO IDOL,
Baka naamoy mo sarili mo? tandaan ang ilong malapit sa bibig?huh?

kung ako ang tatanungin, dapat gumawa sila ng mga astig na palabas…sana habaan nila yung timeslot ng CAMERA CAFE.. ang galing eh..haha
ang galing ng idea ng palabas na yun…it shows na may buhay din kahit mga simpleng employee…haha

for chibambi. waaaaaa

hahaha! that is so funny… visit youtube and seach for ken lee…

mas maganda ata ung taiwanese version

chibambi pabo mo yan nakuang gravatar mo?

For the sake of the fans of the original Japanese manga, I don’t want to see both 2 and 7 fighting over the live action adaptation of Hana-Kimi. It’s also insulting to know that the viewers of this upcoming show are not actually Japanese comic fans, but the die-hard loyalists of both TV networks who are mudslinging each other on who’s version is best, not to mention the trading of accusations over the ratings issue. I’m speaking from a fan’s point of view.

iba kasi pag may quality ang humahawak! walang sinabi ang gme sa mga dubding.. sa gme7 yong dubbing nila parang mga baka ang nagsasalita..hehehe

sa trulalu… im watching hana kimi sa crunchyroll…. pero mas na-appreciate ko po ung japanese version than ung taiwanese version infairness……sori sa mga kapamilya…sa kapuso… s kawhatever…. world peace………………….

but actually.. pansin din ngaun.. hehehe

Anu ba wala ba kayo magawa samahan nyo nalang ako antok na antok na me bwaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

@chibambi

Mangarap ka katulong meron ka…..neh baka nakakalimutan mo labahin mo at hugasin…..tama na posting MOH!

@boyhilig

Saan ka nakatira….mahilig din ako harharharharhar

Sa Technology talagang panalo ang ABS….gnagamitan talaga nila ng mataas na kalidad ang kanilang mga progarams, kahit sa mga talents talagang hindi matatawaran ang HUSAY ng mga ABS talents.. wala pang nakakatapat sina Anne Curtis, Bea Alonzo, Sam Milby, Toni Gonzaga, JOhn LLoyd Cruz and Angelika panganiban pagdating sa pag arte.. malayong malayo si Marian Rivera sa kanila, Dapat tayong mga pilipino marunong mag appreciate ng tintawag na ARTS….

hai.. nakakatawa nga.. la naman sa pagdub yan e. or kung sino man ang may mas magaling na talents. What’s more important is they both give satisfaction to us televiewers in all the shows they aired. thats all! thanks! ciao

Abangan nalang natin…….

This is not the first time on Philippine TV.

Few years ago, nagkatapat din ang Betty La Fea sa both stations. First season sa GMA, 2nd Season naman sa ABS-CBN.

Nakakatawa naman yung nagsasabi na original yung sa Taiwan kaya nga HANAKIMI
Hanazakari no Kimitachi e (花ざかりの君たちへ (”For You in Full Blossom”) paanong naging original yung sa Taiwan e Japanese nga ang Nanazakari no Kimitachi hindi mandarin. Ito ang title kung Mandarin “Hua Yang Shao Nian Shao Nu” (’花樣少年少女’).

At wag sabihin ang ABS ang first na nagpalabas ng Asian drama dahil sabi ng mother ko ay bata pa sya may mga chinese drama na sa Channel 5 and 9. At ang first drama na may tagalog dubbed ay yung pinalabas sa Channel 13. Sana naman bago mag post ay know your facts hindi yung post lang ng post ng kung ano ano. Nagmumukha na kayong fanatics.

catherine, kaya Japanese yan dahil based on a Japanese manga ang Hana Kimi. Pero mas naunang magpalabas ng Hana Kimi drama ang Taiwan kesa sa Japan. Almost 1 year ang gap. Since we’re talking about the drama and not the manga, we can say na mas orig yung Taiwanese version. Know your facts bago ka mag-correct na mali naman.

Taiwanese version: 2006-11-19 – 2007-03-04

Jap version: 2007-07-03 – 2007-09-18

Google is your friend.

as usual copy cat talaga ang gma! gahaman sa ratings kc naman ngayon lang napansin…successful kc ang pag manipulate nila… guys u know who’s way better in dubbing at anong station ang mas may quality show… kahit ano paman yan ratings ratings na yan…wag kayo masyado magmalaki kc abs stars parin ang mas pinaka maraming product indorsement… kaya plssss…lng wag na mag illusion…
and sa nagsabi na na tigok na sa ere ung maging sino kaman dahil sa kawalan ng budget… wala KANG ISIP! palbhasa close minded kc… 6 mos. lng ang running time ng mga serye sa DOS kaya times up na noh… hindi naman kc gaya ng Marimar nyo na paikot ikot lng kayo…para mas mas lalong gumulo ang storya! tsk tsk!

kapamilya rocks!!!

Ang first Asian drama dito sa Philippines ay Amazing Twin na may tagalog dubbed.

O ayan totoong facts yan ha hindi comment ng fanatics.

i’ve already finished watching the both version of hana kimi..JAPANESE version of it is the best

prang anlaki ng Galit niya
sa mundo.. eh mas mukha pa
nGa xang fanatiC kesa sa ‘tin..
hehehe. ..peaCe! godbLess u!=D

hahahah!
kawawa nmn pla gma
wla lng kita q lng nmn s comment nla!
hahah
sabagay totoo nmn tlga ehh!!
GAHAMAN TLGA S RATINGS!!!!!!!!!!!
ahhaha!.., nde lng aq ang nagsabi nun!

bitter ang talo sa ratings ahehehe

sourgraping ahehe na naman ang kapam natics dito hu hu hu..

pag talo talo …… hay naku kelan kaya kayo aasenso sa comments nyong puro pang kanto ng mental haahah

ahahahh!
kakatawa nmn mga comments neo jan!
ahahha!
ako half korean half filipino!
o bka sabihin neo n “ano pake ko sa’yo, wla ako pake kung half ka!”
sure ako yan ang sasabihin ninyo!
alam ko din n hindi nauna ang abs n maglabas ng korean drama and taiwanese drama
laki ako s korea kya wag ninyong lalaitin ang movie nla dahil lng s pinagaawayan ninyong nework ha!

magtatagal lng aq dito ng 3 yrs!
hahhah!
saya!

it seems that u really are familiar with those tactics…
groceries and 500 pesos could really fudge…

@ taga usig

better do some research first… the kapamilya network have already obtained awards long since… both international and national awards.. not to mention it’s emmy nomination. the first ever of a filipino kind… of course networks need not to brag to the viewers about these awards…

ahahah!
sarcastic
thanks kssi kapamilya ka!
ahahah!
kahmsahamnida!

i love ABS-CBN… dubbing? buti pa dito di boring.. pag sa GMA.. naku.maxadong low… di sila nag-aalala kasi manipulated nila ang pampayaman nila… hahahah dahil sa ratings yumayaman.. hahahahah sino ang pera pera? GMA lang… parang PGMA

taga usig Says:
March 21st, 2008 at 9:18 pm

Quality shows comes from quality networks

and a quality network could only be named as such if the awards earned by them has weight..esep esep hahaha

international awards are a very good barometer for such things,
to have a local award is fine but to have an international award is devine../

the networks can tell every viewer that they are of quality… but only the international award giving bodies can confirm the claim…

local awards are just cheap overrated gimmicks of a network..(sino kaya yun hahaha)

>>>>>> yeah right!!!

abs-cbn obtained international awards long since… that is the difference between the kapamilya and the kapuso network. abs-cbn isn’t bragging their international recognition unlike the rival network gma. it’s the proof of staying humble despite of the success. for me, it is a sign of being secure and confident, because afterall they have been undisputed for more than a decade. its quite an achievement that is hard to attain…

GO TEAM KAPAMILYA! evidently, gives true service to the filipino people!!!!

AWAY NG MGA BAKLITA NA KASI

sarcastic: tama nga ang pangalan mo bagay sayo. Super yabang ka buti at least si Jenina San Miguel nanalo e ikaw ano ka.

Kaya nga sa isang forum maraming nagcocomment na sa na tigilan na ang network war kasi nga ang mga katulad nyo na pag nakapagcomment lang ng hindi katulad sa gusto nyo kung ano ano na ang comment.

Tignan na lang natin kung sino ang tatangkilikin ng tao.

Super galing ka nga SARCASTICSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSSS

Someone needs to grab a dictionary and learn what sarcastic means. Yung someone na yun, itago nalang natin sa pangalang ‘catherine’, okay ba?

Mas gusto ko Taiwanese version. Mas good looking ang bidang guy. Tiyaka mas comedy.

@ catherine
i’m sorry. i can’t help but be sarcastic…
and, i agree with melpomene. you betta grab a dictionary and find what sarcastic means…
betta read between the lines of all my comments… and u’ll understand… hahaha (i’m not laughing at you)… hahaha!

and.. i’ll take ur rebuttal as a compliment.. hehehe… thanks… hope u get what i mean…

oh wait! here is what sarcasm (the noun) means:
***Witty language used to convey insults or scorn (from wordweb)

i did it for you… hope ya like it… ^_^

hay naku wag na kasi umasa sa ratings na yan kasi yung agb mga bayaran!!! kaya kayo mga taga kapamilya asa na kayo na mataas lagi ang ratings ng syeetee na yan kahit ang totoo abs ang mataas binabaliktad nila ang ratings..bwahahaha…. kasi sayang din yung milyon2 na bayad ng tga syeetee na yan sa agb noh!!..hhehe..pero ang importante panoorin nyo abs na show wag na kayo maniwala sa ratings na yan… basta ang magandang mga palabas nasa abs sa gma mga gaya2 lang cla…kita nyo lahat ng mga palabas ng dos pinapalabas pa rin nila kahit tapos na like METEOR GARDEN now hana kimi naman hay naku manood nalang ako ng wheel of fortune kesa sa hana kimi nila ang pangit ng bida….hahaha…LOSERSS KANGUSO!!!bwhaha…

Hay naku …maganda talaga yang Hana Kimi Taiwan at Hana Kimi Japan version , sa Taiwan kasi alam nyo na…hmmm…ang gwapo ng bidang lalaki na si WU ZUN ,,,sa GMA kasi di bagay yung boses sa Character na dina dub nila,,,, minsan nga eh ,,napanood ko yung GhostFighter tapos nabigla ako sa Boses ni Dennis ,,,,ang sagwa ng Boses,,,nilipat ko tuloy di ko matagalan… parang tuloy kung sino sino nalang yung nag da dubbing , parang kinuha lang sa tabi tabi…

CE forever

@daniela
neng, nabasa mo man lang ba ung manga? The fact that the manga was written by a japanese doesn’t mean that the japanese adaptation would be better and that it would be the same as that of the comic book.. sabi nga sa wikipedia, the japanese adaptation has significant changes than that of the original story in the manga, again, SIGNIFICANT, meaning malaki ung iniba ng story.. Nabasa ko din ang 1st few chapters ng manga, and true enough, there were changes. example, ung 1st moment nila, where Sano landed on top Ashiya, sa jap nalaglag ung upuan, sa manga, yuujiro (the dog) pushed them while Ashiya was blocking the wind for Sano, again, just like Taiwan. another one, how did Sano discovered that Ashiya’s a girl? sa jap, he overheard it sa conversation nila ng kuya niya, but sa manga, she fainted when Nakatsu accidentally hit her and Sano was to carry her when he felt her breast, then realizing that Ashiya is really a girl. Again, same with the Taiwanese version. tapos sa japanese version, nasa early eps ang pageant na ngcompete si Ashiya and nung lumaban xa sa marathon. eh sa manga chapter 17 na un. not only did they change the story, iniba din nila ung pagkakasunod ng events as they happened sa manga. i believe that the taiwanese adaptation is more closer to the original story because it didn’t come from their country, not like japan, because it originated from them, they could easily change the story line because they could make arrangements with the author to change it.

ryt^^,

haha
from jim25

>>>>>> yeah right!!!

abs-cbn obtained international awards long since… that is the difference between the kapamilya and the kapuso network. abs-cbn isn’t bragging their international recognition unlike the rival network gma. it’s the proof of staying humble despite of the success. for me, it is a sign of being secure and confident, because afterall they have been undisputed for more than a decade. its quite an achievement that is hard to attain…

dont dwell in past dud move on, gma is raking it in and you still cant see it haha
dos “has been” number one in the past but were in the present … has been hahahaah

GO TEAM KAPAMILYA! evidently, gives true service to the filipino people!!!!

s sobrang mag isep paano maka isa
a ayaw nalang tanggapin na talo na sila
r ratings ohh kita . kaso sabi daya .. daya kasi talo sila ahehe
c care naming kapuso sa inyo losers sour graping haha
a always annoyed kasi ang chew kita na sa youtube ang kadayaan di parin umamin haha
s sorry sa inyo number one kapuso
t til you get the truth in side your empty heads
i it will be a kapuso day each day
c calling all chewers hahaha masarap ba ampalaya hahaha..

*applause*

nice try…

i’ll repeat it too

intindihin ang mga kapuso… kaya nga sila kapuso kasi ganyan ang reasoning nila… waaaaaaa….

sarcastic – first ever to donate his brain haha. and survive!!!

the only living brain donor ahehehe – sarcastic

haay naku. . .lets just see kung alin ba talaga mas mganda pag pinalabas na yan.. . . .but for now . . .dont forget to watch PINOY BIG BROTHER TEEN EDITION PLUS!!!ang ganda nun . . .sure akoh dun!!!!mlapit ng magbabay ang maging cnoh ka man. . .ever ma mimis koh un!!

the statement given by the sars person is not true.

i did not accept the brain of that person on one simple reason

the brain in question does not fit the description of a brain hahaha.. it is only the nervous system of an ipis ahehe ewwwwwwwwwww…. hahahaha

da best pa rin ang taiwan version ng HANA KIMI lalo na sa ABSCBN ipapalabas.

gaya-gaya talga ang GMA walang originality bat di na lan kc sila gumaya sa ABSCBN.

ABSCBN ROCKS!!! whoooooooooooo!

wala ng hihirit LOSERS!

@ taga usig
u’r amazing! how do u do that? moving your fingers without using your brain… u’r getting well… lol

tanggapin nyo nalang ang totoo…. bitter kayo kasi di na kayo number 1 hahaha.

go kapusoooooooooooo

t trying real hard to convince non chew believers of chew greatness but
k kept on failing due to lack of
t training .. ala na kasi budget ang dos eh lugi na kasi aheheheh

sarcastic actually is derived from 3 greek words.

sar – meaning s u c k
cas – meaning male g e n t a l i a being removed
tic – a parasite

if put together i would mean

being found of s u c k i n g a dead bleep like a tick on a summer day hahaha

OH I AM SORRY BECAUSE THE UGLY NAME WAS CHIBAMBI!

i already watched these 2 TV series and both are good..but taiwan’s version is way better because it’s more realistic and may kilig factor..sa japan version pretty lang yung girl and hindi sya mukhang lalake kaya parang unbelievable na nakapasok sya sa isang all boys school..
saka galing nga acting sa taiwan unlike sa japanese version parang serious masyado..

ay nku..
ive watch the taiwanese version..
i REALLY LOVE IT!!!

although dko pa na watch ang japanese..
tgnan ko plang pic ng girl e obvious nmng girl tlg!
unlike sa taiwanese, kahit d gnun kganda ang girl sa itsurang guy.
atleast.. by that, massabing guy tlg.. at napportray ng tama..

i even got confuse if tomboy ba tlga ung lead character sa taiwanese (ella) e..
unlike sa japanese na very2 obvious..

and aside sa lead character na si ella..
super nadala din sya ng guy.. (wu chun)
o gosh!! super papable tlg..

compare din sa japanese version..
na hnd gnun ka cute ung guy..

and again.. 2006 ang taiwanese version..
and 2007 and japanese..

so it means.. original tlg ang sa taiwanese..
although nagbase sila sa manga of japan..

my additional flavor prin clang dnagdag at tnanggal pra mpaganda tlg..
sa meteor garder. nauna sa taiwan db..
but did you consider na hnd original ang sa taiwan the fact na nauna cla..

un lng po un..
pra skin original ang sa taiwan..

and i really really love it!!

Hana Kimi in taiwan pilit na ginagaya ito ang Orig!

aba!
at my nkapansin skin!

cno k nmn?!
tga usig?!!!

i dont know u.. but it seems na u know me..
is it bcoz of the pep??
haha.. kakatwa k nmn!

atleast ako d nagpapalit ng user..
unlike u?!

mukang my after shock k pa ng holy week ah..
haha…

i love the hana kimi of taiwanese version!
my problema kb dun??!!

ang papangit ng mga lalaki sa japanese version..
and yah! maganda ung girl,, and very obvious nmn ng girl un!
cla2 lng naglolokohan e..

khit d mganda ung girl sa taiwanese version sa guy look nya..
search mo nlng sa net ang look nya pag girl sya..
wow!!

un lng..

WOW!!

ABS -> HANA KIMI “ORIGINAL”

GMA -> HANA KIMI “FAKE”

ABS -> Original

GMA -> Fake

ABS Fans -> Original

GMA Kapuso Fans -> Fake

for me, mas da best tlaga ang ABS-CBN, kc cla ngpa2katotoo cla, kagaya ng iba diyan, mga PLASTIK! wlang kwenta!! kht na hindi number 1 ang ABS-CBN, tinatanggap nila ito, bali wala lng tlaga sa knila ang pagiging number 1 nila, basta gusto nilang TAYO! mga PILIPINO! na maging masaya, at lagi nilang sinasabi na tayo palagi ang number 1 sa kanila, malaki ang PUSO ng mga taga ABS-CBN, kagaya ng iba diyan, sinasabi na KAPUSO sila, hindi naman marunong magmahal ng kapwa. Kaya mga GMA diyan!wag kayo manira ng ibang networks!cge kayo nga ang number 1, pero nasa ABS-CBN parin ang tunay na minamahal ng bawat pilipino! KAya doon sa mga certified KAPAMILYA,, palagi nating susuportahin ang ABS-CBN! walang kwenta ang GMA!!!!!SUCKS!! SOLID KAPAMILYA TAYO MGA PILIPINO. at sa mga TFC na walang tigil na pagsusuporta sa mga programang inihandog ng ABS-CBN! Maraming SALAMAT sa inyo!KAPAMILYA RULEZ!!SOLID!!

for me, hana kimi in ABS-CBN is more better and by the way matagal ng nakaline-up ang show na ito sa ABS.. another factor is the original one is the taiwanese version and this version will be aired by ABS.. last factor is magaling talaga ang abs sa dubbing.. ( ;

2_perfect..

..yeah prang Joke nga
ung jap.version..hehehe^^,
ok Lng, d ko pa nman tLga
nppanuod kya tinGnan nlng
natin mmya..pero promiSe,
kung base sa traiLers, Ung
sa ABS-CBN tLga ppnuorin
q, aCting,dubbing at pGgng
cLose 2 reaLity..mas anGat
tLga,pro ika nGa nLa, wag
mGhusga hanGgang d pa
nppanuod..eh d ok^^,
..hehehe=)

………ZaH lHat nG MgA TeAM KaPaMiLYA JaN WlAH LaNG
“PROUD TO BE KAPUSO KAMI”!!!!!
………hNd nAndAya ang GMA..CnUnGALiNG C JuLIuS BaBaO..DnAmAY PaH C MiKE EnRiQUeZ…HuMANDA KauH hnding HndI nYa kAuH Ta2ntanan kaPaMilya…
………wLaNg lBan aNg tAiWan sAh jApAn…

…….nAuNa nAh kUng nAuNA
pRo paGaNdahan nLang ng bda…
…….aNg taba kaya ng bida sa taiwan..
pOgi nGa nung partner hnd nman cla bgay..
atleast dun saGMA kht di mxado pogi
mganda nman ung bida…….
say moh…

@ SEGUE

…DHIL JAN SAH CNV MOH FREND NAH TAUH..
…SUBUKAN NTING PANOORIN PARA MABAWAS BAWASAN NMAN UNG RATING NG GMA KC LGI NLANG TAUNG NUM. 1..
IPAEXPERIENCE NMAN NTIN ZAH KNILA PANOH MGING NUM. 1….
…HEHEHE…SHARE OUR BLESSINGS,..

LOVE IT..

wow!!! wow na wow tlga ang ganda nga ng hana kimi e2 ktatapos lng…aztig nkakakilig, comedy, nkakainlove ang ganda tlga…

….uy frend nah tauh ha??
oo iKaW..
IkAw nga oO..

,,,DbA IkAW UN??

C??????

SEGUE,,,

FReNd nah tAuh ha…

pinagtutulunga kc tauh ng mga kapangekngek ehh..

pero nanood ka rin hahaha totoo nmn orig tlga ang hana kimi ng taiwan khit iresearch mo pa! bsta maganda xa d best!!!

Grabe ang cutie ng mga guys dun sa Taiwan version lalo na yung gay guy! Hehe.

…oO kaMuhKah mOh

iKaw nGa

MELPOMENE….

………….gANo BAH UN KAcUtE??

KcInG CuTE BaH Ng GaLIcNg sO SaH KaNtO KaNtO???

WaHaHa

melpomene…

Well, the Japanese version of Hana Kimi is friendship-centric and has more funny scenes than the Taiwanese version. Though, the Taiwanese version is more romance-centric. They’re both nice versions of Hana Kimi, just centered on two different things. But for me, I like the Japanese version better. The plot is nicer than in the Taiwanese version.

If we’re talking about cute guys, they both have their share of cute guys. The Japanese version has Shirota Yuu, Yuusuke Yamamoto, Ikuta Toma (*drool*), Mizushima Hiro, Shun Oguri (though I personally don’t find him cute), Masaki Okada, and Ryo Kimura. Of course that’s just naming a few. There’s quite a lot of cute guys in the Japanese version. The Taiwanese version has Wu Chun, Jiro Wang, Danson Tang, Ethan Ruan, and Gong Ji An. Less cute guys but hey! They’re cute. ^_^

Oh well, it really depends on you. It doesn’t matter if you watch both because they’re both very nice shows. I think it’s a shame to miss out on one just because of what channel’s airing them.

im sorry wla kming pakealam sa ratings na yan…pero infairness ang ganda ng hana kimi knina ah…the best! tlgang orig ang hana kimi ng taiwan pilit tlgang gnagaya, duh! ang hana kimi ng taiwan jan 18 2007, e ang hana kimi ng japan july 13 2007…

errrr

parang virus sa pc hahaha… oist gamit ka naman ng ibang username baho nyan eh

chew fanatics !! kain muna alikabok.. bitter kasi talo sa laban daya daw hahaha

Go ABC 5,.,, mga panggap.,,Gus2 ba sa inu ng kapuso at kapamilya…. tanung mo muna sa kanila kung gus2 ka niya…. hahahaha!!! pinagaawayan nio pa yan.. manood n lng kau ng TV… hahaha!!!

nakoo..
parehas nmng mganda ee..
pero mas ncyahan aku sa taiwan..
haha

4 vogue..

glng mu tsong..tama ka..

2lad nung zaido,kamandag..etc..
d prn matpos tapos..kung anu anu ng kaba2laghan ang nngya2ri ..naka2tawa !!

ee sa abs..
my love story,my action,at my reality show…

taz inuulit nlng ng GMA ung mga nlumang palabas nuon..

la ng maicp na show..

boring ang gma..

ang ganda talaga ng Hana kimi Taiwan kahit pa ulit-ulit ko ng napanood sa you tube,,tawa pa rin ako ng tawa iba talaga pag di ka na tumitingin sa subs,, hindi ko na mahintay ang bukas…

By the way, I watched the first episode of Hana Kimi Japan (I missed the Taiwan version… I’m so sad…), and I must say, Nakao’s dub is perfect for him.

Walang kwenta ang mga kapamilya fans!!! hahaha Niloloko na nga kayo ng harapharapan ng DOS !!! O baka nagbulagbulagan lang kayo???? Remember yung WOWOWEE SCANDAL??? hahaha Mayaman na nga magnanakaw pa!!!! Kawawa naman ang mga pumipila sa inyo!!! Aminin nyo na pangmasa ang GMA7:D hahaha!!! Di katulad ng DOS puro Luv story!!!! hahaha!!!! Tapos lalangawin din!!! Tatagal lang ng tatlong buwan:P hahaha!!! GMA THE BEST!!!!! hahaha!!!!

ang ganda nman preho ang series………
aNu b nman nyan…
tV series lng pag aawayan…….
eH ano nman ngayun
kung mas mganda nga ang gma o abs..
la nman tayung magagawa diba..?
nanonood lng nman tayu….
basta ang nakakasiguru n ginagawa ng lahat
ng 2 istasyun para ma-entertyn tyu
eH anu s tingin ninyung (o sabihin n nting tayu)
ginagawa ntin..
masyado ng mgulo..
bkit gawin n lng ntin ay hayaan ng panuurin ng iba ang gusto nila
alam kung masakit pag cnbhan k
ng pangit ang palabas n pinanonod mo,hindi b?
so bkit pabayaan n lng ntin cla..
para walang away..walang gulo..
pabayaan n lng natin…
kung mag papatuloy to preho lng tayuy masasaktan….
hindi ko hinihinging taposin n tong site n to
ang gusto lng sna
kun may mlasakit kyu s mga taong sumosuporta s kanikanilang gusto
para di cla masaktan..bkit hayaan mo n lng cla..para di cla masaktan

‘Yun lng….cge,..

salamat s site nto…dahil dito nalaman kung maxado ang kahalagahan ng bwat istasyun….

bAwAt tAo mAy iBat-Ibat tAsTe…………….

lHat ng Tao ay may sriling PaniNiwala…..

cge..sLamat……

GOD BLESS..

JAPANESE VERSION IS BETTER!!! ALAM NYO KUNG BAKIT? “HANA-KIMI” COMES FROM JAPANESE MANGA COMICS!!! IT’S MEANS NA GINAYA LANG NG TAIWAN ANG STORY SA JAPANESE ANIME MANGA COMICS!!! KUNG GUSTO NYO MAGRESEARCH PA KYO AT SIGURADONG KAYO ANG MAPAPAHIYA!!!! THE TITTLE “HANA-KIMI” IS A JAPANESE WORD “HANA” MEANS FLOWER:P KAYA KAHIT MAUNA MAN ANG TAIWAN, GINAYA PA DIN YAN SA MGA HAPON!!!!

ANG PIKON LANGING TALO!!!! HAHAHA!!!

edi kung ung japanese version hanakimi ang gusto mo d iyon ang panoorin mo..
kso nga lng, you dont know wat u miss kung dmo ppnoorin ang taiwan version..

i have nothing against jap version.
kso una kong npanood ang taiwanese version and super hangang ngaun na struck pko..

and ung jap version e pnpnood ko plang now, so far ok lng din..
kso lng super looking girl nmn ang girl..
prang kylngan i carry ko p srili ko n dpat boy ung girl dun..

and sbrang bilis ng facing ng jap version..

but il finish it padin pra macompre tlg which is which..
but as of now!
i love wu chun!!
hay….

@bigpoppapump
i suggest you take your own advise on researching. have you ever read the manga? have you watched the taiwanese adaptation? how can you call that research if you’ve only watched one version? hindi porket alam mo ang translation ng hana e ang galing mo na.. alam mo ba kung bakit hana kimi un? short cut lang yon pare. HANAZAKARI NO KIMITACHI E ang title ng manga na sinulat ni hisaya nakajo which means For You in Full Blossom. Tinranslate ng Taiwan bilang Hua Yang Shao Nian Shao Nu. xempre, ittranslate nila kasi taiwanese ung audience nila. mas marami kang matututunan kung hindi puro salita lng ung ginagawa mo. hindi porke’t nakita mo sa google, research ng matatawag un. ;)

i really like the opening theme of hana kimi tw version..
ang cute..

Wahahaha.. Is that wat you call best?! Wow! Mahirap bang tanggapin na talo ang SHETE mo sa quality? Nyahahahaha.. Kahit sinong tanungin mo maganda ang summer ID ng DOS. Suyurin ba naman kasi para magpamigay ng sardinas.. Nyahahahaha.. And speaking of laos, tingin ko nasa SHETE ang mga laos.. mga walang career.. Yun at yun ang nilalabas na artista. Kasi takot baka langawin pag sumubok eh.. Nyahahahaha

Wawa ka naman.. Hana Kimi of Taiwan was the first adaptation of the japanese manga. Ung Jap adaptation nahuli, mas nauna ang Taiwan version, and by the way kung pagbabasehan mo ung manga mas close ung story nung sa Taiwan unlike sa Jap na may changes.. Kung yaw mong manood ng version ng Taiwan e d wag, as if malaking kawalan ka naman as a viewer.. Hahahahaha

PUSTAHAN TAYO NANOOD KA DIN NG JAPANESE VERSION! PANO MO NAMAN NAHULAAN NA MAS MALAPIT ANG VERSION NG TAIWAN? HAHAHA!!!! BUKING!!!

CATHERINE THE BEST!! HEHE

Si Wu Zun lang ang gwapo sa HanaKimi nila no, pero sa Hanazakari no Kimitachi e, umuulan kaya ng gwapo dun ~ classmates pa lang ni Mizuki e, saka mas gwapo naman si Shirota Yuu kay Wu Zun ano. At ano naman yang Ella Chen na yan? Ang pangit, e hindi naman ganun ang itsura ni Mizuki dapat nga bishounen-like!!!

Saka ano itong sinasabi ng ABS na orig ang Hana Kimi nila? Sa MANGA na galing JAPAN kaya ang orig nun as in “HANAzakari no KIMItachi e”. Namimirata lang sila ng story katulad sa “Hana Yori Dango”, “Peach Girl” at “The Devil Does Not Exist (Devil Beside Me)”. Kung hindi lang namirata ang Taiwan e baka sinunod din ng Japan ang manga storyline katulad sa “Nodame Cantabile”. Parang ganito yun e: Kung sa Pilipinas galing yung original story tapos ginawan ng drama ng ibang bansa at gumawa din ng version ang Pinas, mas sasabihin mo ba na orig yung sa ibang bansa? At saka may sarili mangaka ang Taiwan ha? Si Nicky Lee na author ng “Youth Gone Wild” at “The One” Bakit hindi yung gawing drama ng Taiwan?

Eto lang ha Japanese version pa rin ang da best. Kung original storyline ang hanap niyo edi basahin niyo na lang japanese manga kaysa manood ng isang taiwanese drama na namirata lang.

Nakaw! tlgang di nag iisip, itanong mo kay google!

bravo!

KAPUSOs really have the best reasoning abilities… that’s why they are kapusos…

NUOD NLNG KAU NG GUS2 NYO, !!AWAT NA!!

Waha. da best daw oh! Ngekngek

ang masasabi ko lang parehas maganda ang version ng hana kimi, pero katulad ng sabi ng iba mas magaling mag dub ang sa abs-cbn at mas na eenjoy ko ang storya sa abs kasi natutuwa ako sa role ng characters.

kung ico2mpare ang lead actors, obviously mas ok ang taiwanese…and kung lead actress xmpre ung japanese…hmmm… pro parehas namang ok ang hana kimi,, yun lang mas maganda dub ng ABS……hmmm bitin lang ang taiwanese version….
Just watch it…..may kanya kanya tayong opinion…at hindi natin kayang i-please ang lahat….
NO OFFENSE,…

NAKAKASUKA ANG KAPUSO NIO!
mga kanguso jn
@bigpoppapump

gus2 q lng lnwin.
“GMA HANA KIMI” “dw”
oo mgnda ang hana kimi japan version.
ang problema nga lng.
ndi krpt dpt s GMA KANGUSO ang gnung klaseng show.
kc ngmu2kang ewan ung show.

s mga ngssbing “show lng pinagaawayan p”.
bt p kau ngkoment s site n e2?.
ee ang title nga “Hana Kimi Japan(GMA 7) VERSUS Hana Kimi Taiwan (ABS-CBN 2)”
ee pra san p ung word n VERSUS db????
no offense aa.

@RODEZA.
tEaM kpMiLya taU!.
hehehhe.

geh c0mment p.
freed0m of speech!.

@bigpoppapump uLi
mahal n mahal mu gma aa.
e2 lng mssbi q.
ANG MGA GMA, MGA CORRUPT.
gets?
CORRUPT!.
paLag?

~to bigpoppapump

ahm “mamatay na mndaraya?”
atleast we are not born cheaters!
what? manonood ng japanese hana kimi? ikaw. manuod ka?
pakielam ko sayo? tungkol s bilihan ng awards.”have you proven it yet?”
txaka anue nmn kung nmimili cila ng awards? hindi lng kce afford ng GMA yun. how poor. yung GMA hindi marunong mgbuildup ng stars!
tambakan lng ng patapon s ABS! db 22o nmn?

OO CORRUPT CILA.!

Wala ako sa bahay ng Monday afternoon kaya hindi ko napanuod yung Hana Kimi ng ABS at GMA, pero prior to that eh napanuod ko na yung first three episodes ng Hana Kimi Taiwan at uber sa ganda. Kahapon nakapanuod ako ng Hana Kimi sa ABS at natuwa ako dahil walang masyadong pinutol na eksena. Sinubukan kong panuorin yung sa GMA, pero inantok ako at inilipat ko na lang sa Music and Lyrics, yung pelikulang palabas sa HBO.

Im proud to be kapamilya…

tama mas maganda nga ung japanese version and un ung original na hana kimi.!

mas maganda ang taiwanese version mas nakakatawa! and mas realistic dahil mukha talagang lalaki ung girl…

ok.mas reaListic ang
oriG, again oriG! hehehe^^,
peaCe!=)

mas maganda ang hana kimi mg ch.2 kc mas kaabang-abang dahil sa mga back ground songs tulad ng crazy love ni kimchiu…!!!mas maganda in terms of the actors and actresses…

Guys, I think you’ve all gone so far from the original topic which is the Japan version of Hana Kimi versus the Taiwan version of Hana Kimi. This isn’t a debate on which channel is better. The channels were placed in the title so that those who haven’t watched the non-dubbed version of these shows know which Hana Kimi version we’re talking about. Stop wasting other people’s time.

To those who commented on the opening song of the Taiwanese version of Hana Kimi, I love that song too! It’s so fun to listen to. ^_^

About Ella (Taiwanese Ashiya/Rui Xi) looking more boyish than Maki (Japanese Ashiya), I still like Maki better. Ella’s acting was stiff and a bit over the top and Maki’s was more natural so even though Ella looks more butch than Maki, I still like Maki better.

And about Wu Zun being better than Shun, I agree! Well, I haven’t read the manga so I don’t know which of them portrays San better but Wu Zun did a great job of being both aloof and sweet all at the same time. Shun was too cold and his character was only… endearing during the last 2/3 episodes.

Lastly, they’re both original in their own way. They just tackled the story differently. Most say that Taiwan is more loyal to the story but some say it also deviated from the story. So quit arguing over that.

As for me, I’m still a Hana Kimi Japan lover. I find it funnier and more entertaining. The Taiwan version seemed a bit draggy in some parts. But I love both Nakatsu’s! XD Ikuta Toma and Jiro Wang are

I love Uchi! (Oguri Shun- Gokusen I) and as Sano in hana- kimi Japan… pretty din si Ashiya…

Pero mas gus2 q ung Taiwanese version kasi funny xa… and ang cute ni Ella…ㅋㅋㅋ

PROUND TO BE KAPUSO K JAN!

KAPUSO?!
HEH!
PRANG NDE BAGAY N KAPUSO!

XE HUDAS EHHH!

SAGAPAL XE S RATINGS!!!!

The truth is..mas the best, verygood, heartwarming, funny, and very delicous ang bawat episode ng taiwanese version…ung mga cast sa channel 7, mukhang mga malnourished, kulang sa vitamin compare sa cast ng taiwan–di katulad ng bida sa taiwan, super bodylicious talaga, kahit ung gay doctor–talo na naman ang GMA@@
mamimigay na nman ng sardinas yan!!!!

i already watched the two shows in dvd format.. pero s tingin ko mas maganda ang japanese version though animated yung acting ng mga bida.. at mas gusto kong magkatuluyan ang supporting role na guy kesa dun sa lalaking bida.. yung taiwanese version i was bored by the girl kasi and pangit nya at mas mababaw ang dahilan nya sa pagpunta s taiwan.. pro kung ieedit ng abs ung ibang boring scenes baka lumabas na mas maganda ito.. kaya dun sa mga manonood ng hana kimi treat both show as if there not alike para maappreciate nyo yung story kesa icompare habang sinusubaybayan nyo.. pro mas maganda talaga magdub ang abs kesa gma..

NAKAKAINIS TALAGA ANG GMA………..ANG PANGET NG PAG DUB NILA…..BUTI NA LANG MAGANDA MAG ACT ANG MGA ACTRESS AND ACTORS…..
ANG CUTE NG GUY S TAIWAN VERSION…….ANG CUTE TALAGA NG SHOW O PALABAS NG TAIWANESE…AND CUTE DIN NAMAN ANG JAPANESE…..HINDI P AQ NAKAPAGDESIDE KUNG ANO ANG MAS MGANDA……BASTA SURE AQ MAGANDA PREHOO…BAD TALAGA YUNG GAY-DOKTOR S TAIWANESE AT JAPANESE VERSION PAG SAMANTALAHAN B NAMN ANG BABAE…SANA DUMATING AND BIDA SA TAIWANESE VER AT SAGIPIN ANG GURL..AND DUN S JAPANESE VERSION NMAN SANA DUMATING YUNG OTHER BIDA,HINDI C SANO..YUNG ISA…
ANG GANDA TALAGA NG PALABAS..

hahaha1 again it’s me… grabe super ganda ng Taiwanese version… hahaha walang kwenta ang GMA 4 me…! mas maganda parin ang ABS-CBN… pero wag sanang ma o offend… hehhehe d best lang talag ksi ang ABS-CBN!!!

para sa akin naman okay ung both versions pero mas nagustuhan ko ung HANA KIMI NG JAPAN. nakakatuwa and okay ung mga actors. ung sa taiwan version kc cute ung guy kaya lng ung babae… no commnt. tska ang babaw ng reason nya sa pagpunta dun sa school. bsta ung sa japan super nagustuhan ko lalo na ung supporting actor.

tama! tama! maganda nga ung 2 versions! mganda ung sa taiwan kaya lng ung actress ay d ko nagustuhan. ung sa japan super ganda! kaya lng sana iba ung lead na actor.. super gusto ko dn ung supporting. bsta 4 me HANA KIMI JAPAN IS BETTER THAN HANA KIMI TAIWAN PERO UNG 2NG HANA KIMI AY MAGANDA!

ang cute ng lalaki s hana kimi yung isang bida hindi si sanohh…cool nice talaga mag acting………………………nakakatawa…..
MAS BETTER ANG HANA KIMI JAPAN !
NYC DIN NMAN SANA ANG HANA KIMI TAIWAN ….

BASTA D BETTER ANG HANA KIMI JAPAN..ANU NMAN NGAYUN KUNG DI CLA GAANONG MGA GWAPO…BASTA NYC ACTING NOH..NADADALA NMAN NYAN…….khit panget p ang dubbing………………………………………..
BLEH>..>………..

walang kwenta ung comment in IbA kc ung stations ung pinagku-kumpara nila… and anu naman kung sino ang nauna,

i watched both versions and mas maganda talaga ung sa japanese version. cute ang characters, di katulad nung sa taiwanese ver. ung leading guy lang ung cute, ung girl hind! and compared dun sa jap. ver. lahat ng characters maliban dun sa leading guy dun sa tai. masyadong comedy umarte kaya ndi na balance ung pagiging comedy nya kasi corny na…
for short,… corny ung sa tai ver.

nice nman preho ang hana kimi japan ang hana kimi taiwan,kasu mas type ko ang hana kimi japan.tulad nga ng sabi ng iba,nakakatawa talaga yung suporting actor.tama-tama lng ang pag act nya.medyu matcho n pagka-over kunti.tamang tama talaga.
teka muna.may cutre n lalaki ang lumabas kanina..yung kalaban ni sanoh s competion.ang cut nya mas cute p xa s taiwanese guys.hahahah

I love the 2 version but i love hana kimi (taiwan) para saken maganda ella chen at hindi xia o.a. sa pagganap niya,, nakakatawa nga cia bagay na bagay cla ni brian

i love taiwan version..
weeeeeehhhh…
ang gwapo p n jian..
finish n aqng ng.watch ng taiwan version
d best…..
i started to wtch japan version nd i find 8 boring..
obvious n ang gurl ay GURL
d kgya n rexie, prang boi tlga..
panget p ng leading man s Japn version..
la tlgang kwenta ang GMA,
and dr dubbing, sucks!
obvious n ngmamadali ang GMA pra may tym p silang mkbigay ng sardinas plus 500 pesos.. lol

gOsh!cnu yung guy n bida s hana kimi taiwan
ang gWaPo niA eVer!At mgaling p kumanta
Go tAQiwan!………Go tAiwAn!………..

HMMMMMMMM!!!!!
huwag na kayong magaway kasi wala rin namang mangyayari eh ano naman kung mas magaling yung taiwan o yung japan WALA nagaaway lang tayo eh!!!pero para sa akin mas cute yung jap ver. cute kasi ni ashiya eh hehehehehe

super violent

yung nasa taas

talagang kapuso siya forever

tang ina wlang binatbat yan kapuong yan patapon yan…………..HELLO!!!!!!!!!!!
hana kimi plang sa abs-cbn laban sa gma wala ng binatbat yang kapuso nyo!!!!!!!!!yaccccckkkkkkkkkkyyyyyyy………..taiwanise version my kilig effect…..eh ung japan ano???PATAPON….AY HINDI ung GMA 7 PLA UNG PATAPON…HAHAHAHHEHEHEHE…….gayagaya tlaga yang 7 na yan khit kelan…..PROUD TO BE KAPUSO PA KAU…SAGWA KAYA…..
TEAM KAPAMILYA GO…GO….GO

cno ba yang unknown na yan???? ashiya ka pa…..

Huh? wala namanng kaso kung abs or gma ang magpapakabas. ang importante, ienjoy nyo na lang ung pinapanood niyo. besides, sa totoo lang, maganda naman pareho ung japanese at taiwanese version, may variety sa kwento kaya di kayo magsasawa. tska para wag nyo na pag-awayan yung dubbing, panoorin nyo na lang sa crunchyroll, original voices pa..
ano rin bang mapapala niyo kung mag-away kayo dahil dyan? wala di ba? so i-enjoy niyo na lang panonood ha? =)

para sakin super over ever the best ang HANA KIMI JAPAN!!!!!!!!! lalong lalo na c NAKATSU!!!!!!!!!

hey! ABS-CBN is the ORIGINAL! GMA’s a FAKER! ok?!?! and Besides Jiro Wang and Wu Chun ARE THE BEST! ALTHOUGH, I STILL WANT MY MILLIOINARE BOYFRIEND!

weee… mas maganda naman tlga halos lahat ng shows ng abs compared to GMA .. errr..

ka-funny tlga ng hana kimi sa ABS… i sooo love it! :D hahah

Kung pag-uusapan lng nman kung anu mas magandang version ng Hana Kimi ung sa TAIWAN syempre ang gwapo ng artista at bagay pa si Ella sa character. kung gusto mo mkita itsura nila search for “fahrenheit “band si Wu Chun at Jiro wang ay member nun. singer na, gwapo pa magaling pa umarte at kumanta.Si Ella naman sa S.H.E band magaling na kumanta best actress pa. Walang ibabat bat ung sa JApan actors naku search for the image nlang ni Ella,WU chun At Jiro WAng…….lalo na sa youtube ung MV nila hanip ang galing talaga…….. Naku mga kapuso wag na kayo umasa OK lng nman mangarap U can say it but don’t make it a habit “Liers go to hell”

solid Kapamilya,

uhm.. Im afraid to say, but I got lots of chinese friend from online. They said that Farenheit isnt really that they still lacked of talent. Theyre just a young and good looking guy (actually they only told me that it was only Wu Zhun who is popular in their group) thats why theyre popular in Taiwan. In addition of Hana Kimi where Jiro and Wu Zhun is part. This isnt from me, They said they still need to improve their dancing, singing and acting. It based on some chinese people and fans. They even comparing them with DBSK (the korean boyband who sang the “The Legend” OST which recently aired on GMA 7 primetime) Sorry for saying this.

hindi naman mukhang lalaki yung sa japanese GO FAHRENHEIT AND S.H.E!

wala na lang care yung iba kung mas gusto namin yung taiwanese OK?

hindi na rin namin kayo papakilaman.

GMA madami nagkakacolon cancer sa ginagawa nyo C;

at yung japan parang ang labas, parang gaya-gaya
remember na japan nag-originate ang manga. therefore may karapatan din ang japan na gawing live-action yun

heller. japanese word kaya ang HANA KIMI . palagay lagay pa ng the original ang ABS .. wohoo! PROUD TO BE KAPUSO!!!

and by the way. nauna ang GMA. bakit ba nagpalabas ng hana kimi? dahil sa coffee prince. :))

for me..hana kimi japan is much better!..nbbbwan kc aq s dhilan ni ella kung bket cia bumalik s taiwan..at least ung s hana kimi japan..may sense..sbe nga nung doctor dun eh..umalis n lng cia kung may gus2 cia dun s lalake..o dba?..may values pa..bsta i prefer hana kimi japan!…!

PAHABOL
KAHIT ANUNG GWIN NYU MAS MAGANDA ANG JAPANESE VERSION.

KAHIT ANG SETTINGS NG SHOW O PALABAS AY NAPAKANYS….
TULAD NGA NG SABI NG IBA..
BLEH!

Duh……… mas maganda tlga ung sa Taiwan Normal lng nman na ganun ung acting ni Jiro kc pinoportayed nya tlga ung character pnapkita nya na confuse sya sa sexuality nya kaya lgi nyang kinakausap srli niya . Ikaw b nman magkakagusto sa kapwa mo lalaki o babae di kaba maguuguluhan pero alam mo sa sarili mo na tunay na babae o lalake ka sympre magtatanung ka at normal lng na maging emotional bagay nga sa kanya ung role ang galng tlga kita na totoo na parang true story na iyon mas nakakakilig ang Taiwan version dahil lging pinoprotektahan ng lalake si Ella at nakakatawa rin lalo na si Jiro at kaibigan nyang 3 lalo na si Da shun ung mahilig makwento tnkol sa spirits at trilling rin kung anung mga susunod na mangyayari. D tulad sa Japan ver. d mukhang totoo ung acting nla. sla ung finufocus kc bida sla pero d nman nakakalimutan nla tulad ni Senior Nan,Yang Yang, Julia ,KK At marami pa .D tulad Gma corney at di ko ma feel ung pinoportayed na feeling nung character means d ko na fifeel na totoo ung acting nla para ayaw nla gawin ung novela Solid HANA KIMI TAIWAN 2!!!!!!!!!!…….

Naku OK lng kung manuod kayu ng Japan ver. pero para skn mas mgnda ung sa Taiwan kc na fifeel ko ung gustong ipalabas nung character. Napanoud ko na un sa Dvd Taiwanese ung lang. pero may subtitles nman maganda tlga ung Taiwan mas Exciting lalo na sa Huling parte……

Galing tlga nla Umarte solid Taiwan ver. 2 at pano nsma ang chinese dto japan at taiwan lng nman ung pinaguusapan . D nmin bnabase sa gwapo o hndi trailer palang halatang mgnda na at pnu nyo nsbi na d bgay kay ella mging babae nkita nyu na ba syang nka pngbabaeng damit at may make-up……….. cguraduhin nyo mga snsabi nyo

hoy mga kangusong limbungan…how could u say nga maot ang skul sa hanakimi taiwanese…nalibat ba mo…mas maot gud tong skul sa hanakimi japanese pirti jud gamaya ….basta bisag unsaon jud mas nindot ang hanakimi taiwanese

Hi!!!!!!!! Galing Tlga Ng HANA KIMI TAIWAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!…

mas nakakatawa ang hana kimi ng abs kesa sa gma, masarap panoorin lalo na mga gwapo yong mga characters nla… sayang c doc gwapo pa naman hehehe

bulag ang mga KAPUSO!!!!!!!!

HANA KIMI TAIWAN in ABS is MUCH BETTER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

try to watch it!!!!!

you’ll love it for sure, open ur mind…:)

hoy ng hindi dahil sa coffee prince walang hana kimi noh!!!!!!!!

basta walang tatalo sa jap version ng hana kimi !!!!!!!!

walang akong pakialam sa solid kapamilya nyo!!!!!

gaya gaya lang naman yang kapangekngek !!!!!!!!

hahahahahahahaha

mas maganda ang HANA KIMI SA ABS-CBN! kung ayaw nyong maniwala, mag-search nga kau FAHRENHEIT or Fei Lun HAI! GMA LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOSSSSSSSSSSEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEERRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!

PARA WALA’Y AWAY, PANGUTOT NALANG MO! OK? MGA PALA-OTOT!!! ;-)

panoorin nyo na lang kaya pareho.
syempre kung ano ang mas gusto nyo, yun yung sasabihin nyo na mas maganda.
iba iba tayo ng opinyon.

naresearch ko n ang mga chraters nym sa japanee at d pahuhuli ang taiwanese dhil mas gusto q yun:
NAKATSU POH..PALIBHASA WALANG PINAG ARALAN ANG BASTOS NG, BUNGANGA NG IBA
BUMALIK K S PINANGGALINGAN MO
KAHIT MAS BETTER ANG TAIWANESE O SBHIN N NTING PAREHO TAYUNG OPINION WAG KA MAGSALITA NG MASAMA SA IBA
COMMENT KA NG MAAYOS!
LA TAYUNG MGAWA KUNG ANU ANG GUSTO NG IBA
WAG IDAAN SA BASTOS N PANANALITA
ANG SAGWA

OO NGA PLA KYA PLA WALA NG PERA ANG ABS-CBN KASI KAILANGAN PA NILA BAYARAN YUNG MGA NAMATAYAN AT NASUGATAN SA ULTRA-STAMPEDE!!! HEHEHE:P GO GMA7!!! GANDA NG MGA COMMMENT NG KAPUSO!!! HAHAHA HANAKIMI JAPAN THE BEST!

nakakainis talaga ang mga taong naninira sa abs!!!GRRRRR!!!!!i really hate them!!!!ang GMA ay GAYA2X lang naman lagi eh!!!

hana kimi taiwan is way better than hana kimi japan!!!why??
hana kimi taiwan is much funnier and much livelier(because of the light)than hana kimi japan.although the girl from japan is much cuter youll still look at its leading male character…we all know that girls love good lookin guys and theyll only watch a show if the guy looks good!!and the song!!hana kimi taiwan is much beter!!i love zen me ban1!
and i love hana kimi taiwan because wu chin lin shiang nan and jiro wang is there!!(my crush)

^so what?

wohoo! +_98*& galing mo!! +_98*& rock!! GMA is the no.1

to mariel:

Uh… you do know that the guy you’re talking about that’s the counterpart of Wu Zun in Hana Kimi Japan is Shun Oguri, one of the “F4″ in Hana Yori Dango. He’s the blond hair guy there. Hello? Weird much.

And I love Hiro! He’s so awesome.

By the way, I’m a fan of Fahrenheit too.

————————————————-

for everyone else who probably haven’t watched the two versions but keep making judgments based on only the people who are part of the show:

Watch both before you judge. And make better comments. Sheesh! My brain cells are dying just reading your comments.

to bigpoppa:
uhm.
cnasbi mo bng magaLing nga clang magbuiLd ng stars???.
da heLL?
oo mgaLing nga c righard gutierrez ks0 isa lng cia s mga stars n cnasbi mong mgaLing n mabibiLang s kamay!.
uhm c angaL locsin b?
FYI ms o mr bigpoppa!
c angeL locsin p0 ay nagworksh0p s ABS CBN bg0 cia umakting s GMA kangus0!
kya mabiLis magtyugi ng sh0ws b?
kase po aLam niLa na kapag ang shows pinaglumaan n ng panahon dhiL s s0brang tagaL magsasawa na ang tao ka2Lad ng MARIMAR ng KANGUSO.
duh?!
KAKASUKA n.
thank goodness natap0s n!.

CORRUPT po tLaga ang GMA.
kya nga may ebidaensya ABS db?

hmmm.
for this comment im defending XXIX bc0z she’s my frend as weLL as ABS-CBN dhiL quaLity shows lng pnapaLabs niLa di ka2Lad s GMA mga patap0n!!!
oo nga pLa..

msyadong harsh ang c0mment.
pede umayos k?!
ano paLag?!

Daal: sabi mo ba eh ung mas papatok, ganon ba eh mas pinag uusapan ngayon ang HANA KIMI THE ORIGINAL, pag sa ratings naman talo ABS kasi nga MANIPULATED NA YAN ITS CREDEBILITY IS NO MORE!!!

to daal:

yes im a fharenheit lover and hana yori dango lover din pero si matsumoto jun atsi inue mao lang naman gusto ko sa hyd kasi magaling yung chemistry nila!!!
thank you kasi gust mo ang fharenheit……ahm gusto ko sinabi mo.your right!this sight is a fight between two shows at hindi ang networks!!

hanakimi taiwan is d best…….

to daal:
ok you want a comment concerning the plot of the story:

mas funny ang taiwanes version and mas totoo!!!at yung story mas interesting!!although magkahawig lang ang story mas maganda pa rin ang taiwanes v kasi nga mayroon silang uniqueness na hindi kahit kailan makokopya ng japan!!
and mind me mas original ang taiwan kasi sila ang naunang ipinalabas!!

to all pipol who are concerned sa ratings:
nagkataon lang siguro na pareho ang show in different version ang ipalalabas and how can you say na namanipulate na ang ratings na wala pa ngang sapat na katibayan yan!!
ang ibig sabihin na no. ang gma sa manila lang but when it comes to province nangnguna ang abs!!

i really like hana kimi taiwan not because the cast are handsome and cute ……….but the reason is that i like the way they act………………………

ang tamad ng gma!!
buti pa ang abs ginawan talaga ng english ang themesong ng spring waltz and ginawan ng filipino ang theesong ng princess hours para mas maintindiahn ng mga filipino ang song!!
atsaka sa hana kimi fit na fit sa show ang kanat na km chui dahil sa sobrang inlove niya kay quan ay nagpanggap siyang guy!!crazy love nga!!

OMG ganda tlga ng HANA KIMI TAIWAN

FYI mas magaling tlga umakting ung taiwanese at patok tlga ung mga shows nila like “METEOR GARDEN” & “HANA KIMI” WAHAHAHAHAHAH……………………

thats right celyn!!

theyre campaining??

ah i see!!its because they know wu zun would be a hit!!

sorry they couldnt do that because there are still pipol who love wu zun and that includes me

okay okay. kapamilya na kung kapamilya kapuso na kung kapuso. bsta panoodin nyo muna ung 2 versions bago kayo humusga. malamang kung ano ung napanood nyo un ung sasabihin nyong maganda. panoodin nyo kc ung dlwa.

MAGANDA PAREHONG VERSIONS. PAREHONG MAY ORIGINALITY! PAREHONG NAKAKATAWA! PAREHONG NAKAKAKILIG! dba ang importante namn nasiyahan tau sa pinanood natin. tska sa 2 versions na 2 my mga nakilala taung poging actors tulad nila wu zun at nakatsu! tama na ung awayan sa dlwang stations!

sa mga nagsasabi na kapuso people suck. doesn’t make you suck even more to be that low to say that they suck. just because you watch another channel. come on. i don’t even think i want to comment here. it’s so pathetic.

by the way. i watched both. its both nice. can’t you just judge without including the channel whatever. japan’s more funny. really, watch it. stop comparing without watching both.

yes mariel,

try searching for it…you’ll see what i mean.
they’re campaining. i was browsing for some info about wu zun and the upcoming series “basketball of fire” he is shooting with jerry yan and alan luo. i opened a site made by jerry yan fans and i read a comment there that calls for f4 fans to watch hana kimi japan even if they are kapamilya and not to watch hana kimi taiwan coz they don’t want other taiwanese boybands except f4. pwede ba yun?

(^_^)v: no offense meant but, why can’t abs-cbn use the title hana kimi? that’s the title of the series! and the company that made hana kini taiwan paid the maker of the manga for the rights of the title! pumayag nga ang may-ari ng manga, ikaw hindi?

come to think of it. it’s taiwan which releases first a live adaptation of a manga and when it hits, japan follows. look at meteor garden. it was a monster hit then japan made it’s own adaptation. then it’s hana kimi. hana kimi taiwan finished with 50% of the audience share. then again japan made it’s own adaptation. bakit kaya? does it mean taiwanese tv companies have more faith in manga creators than the japanese? or the taiwanese can see a hit far more than the japanese. there are lots of japanese manga that were made into live adaptations in taiwan. and lots of careers were launched because of it. the best examples are jerry yan and f4. now it’s wu zun’s time.

and yes mariel…there are people who are beginning to LOVE WU ZUN!

gosh kau ha di man lng kau marunong manuod kung wat show mas maganda……xmpre better ang hana kimi taiwan……………………….babooooooooooooooooooooooooo hanakimi japan……………………………kapamilya always

hay naku mga gurls…………………………….i know naman na mas nagandahan talaga kayo sa HANA KIMI TAIWAN…………………………..but you just pretend na you dont like it kasi hindi nyu matanggap na mas magandang pumili ng palabas ang ABSCBN……………………..oi aminin………………………………HANAKIMI TAIWAN ……………………ITO ANG MAS MAGANDA

..wEll obviously,,abs-cbn naman ang panalo jan.. im sure big hit na naman yan..ever since talo naman talaga yang gma eh kya nandadaya kasi hindi tumatanggap nang pag katalo..wel sory nalang ang mga kapuso..your LOOSER…

harhar..mas nkakakilig ang sa abs pero mas magawapo ang sa sa gma..c wu chun lng gwapo sa 2..sa gma lhat lalo n c sekime kyogo..hehe..wag n kau mag away awy dyan..

okie..

para sakin ms maganda pa rin ang hana kimi japan kahit anong mangyari. pag pinanood lng ng walang dub… ms maganda ang hana kimi japan!

To all viewers of Hana Kimi, neither of the two adaptation the Japanese or the Taiwanese, I want to tell you all guys that the most important is we’ve enjoy watching. Even if the two shows or television series have the same title or I can say quiet same story, the two shows have a side that make them both original. This site will help us to express our own comment and know others comment. We must put to ourselves that we have difference opinions and we people, should respect it. If you like to support your own Hana Kimi version you should remember other’s feelings, you should make sure that you don’t hurt them. You can support your own Hana Kimi version without using bad words when writing or I can say typing your comment.
As a viewer, I really more enjoy watching the Taiwanese version though the Japanese version is also funny. The advantage of Japanese version is having a pretty female protagonist while the Taiwanese version has cute female protagonist. The most advantage of the Taiwanese version is having handsome characters. I am not saying that the Japanese version don’t contain handsome actors, I can say that they are quiet cute. I am a great fanatic of the Japanese TV series especially when it comes from Manga. Even though Japanese get the story in Manga, they always change or add more situation, sequence to make it different. The example of it is the Hana Kimi (Japanese version). The Taiwanese version really followed the Manga and for me they’ve succeeded to adapt it.
If I will choose according love with funny moments, I will rather choose Hana Kimi Taiwanese version but if I need to select the version has cute moments with challenging obstacles, I’ll rather select Hana Kimi Japanese version. Both TV series have originality. And I know that’s why other people keep watching that shows or series.

ou nga..iagree with you!
kapamilya din ako pero gus2 ko ung hana kimi japan!haha!!!!!
i luv u nkatsu!
plss let’s keep watching hana kimi japan!
cguradong mgeenjoy pa kau..
mamumulat pa kau sa realities ng buhay.

tnx 2 ol hana kimi japan fanatics!

hmmm, mganda tlga ung hana kmi ng dos, nkakakilig pa, hahahah! tska ang my itsura lng sa hana kimi ng 7 si takizuki b un? ung my golden foot din, hmm.. think twice hana kimi of 7, u were just imitating the shows of channel 2, i feel pity for you guys, i dont care about the ratings, what matter here is the hana kimi that the two station is airing currently, ol i can say, THE BEST ANG HANA KIMI NG DOS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Mas maganda Hana Kimi Japan, super cute ni Maki Horikita, wahahaha… mukhang baboy yung sa abs-cbn, toinkz* chaka ang astig naman ni Shun Oguri eh, Rui Hanazawa, lolz… yung mga drama ng taiwan ay galing rin nmn sa mga japanese manga.. gaya nlang nung devil beside you… dapat ang topic nito.. Jun matsumoto vs Shun Oguri.. hahahaha

mas maganda kung english subtitles nlng

Ikenai Taiyou~ dan dan dan dandan~~~

Peach~ lewlz

i like the japanese version better than the taiwanese. hindi dahil kapuso ako or what ha. mas gusto ko lang talaga yung japanese version ng hana-kimi. ung iba kc solid kapamilya kaya lng cnasabi na d dw maganda ang HANA KIMI JAPAN. JAPANESE VERSION is WAY BETTER THAN TAIWAN. I LOVE WU-CHUN AND NAKATSU!

first of all.. malamang sasabhin mo na mas maganda ung isang version kung ung isa lng ung napanood mo. regardless sa station mas maganda ung hana kimi japan. swear. kahit na napogian ako kay wu-chun mas feel kong panoodn ung hana kimi japan. nabilib dn ako kay nakatsu. ang cute and ang funny nya. pag d pagbabatayan ang station.. mas maganda tlga ang hana kimi japan.

mas gus2 ko prin ang hana kimi sa ABS kes sa GMA

wl nmang cnb ang cast ng hana kimi sa GMA sa cast ng hana kimi ng ABS
hlt nmang mas lmang ang cast na hana kimi ng ABS……………

owwwwww. anong walang cnabi ang cast ng hana kimi japan? bulag ka ba.. palibasa un lng kc pinanood mo e. panoodn mo kc pati ung japanese version. MAS MAGANDA YON. JAPANESE VERSION is the best. wala akong pakeelam kahit kapamilya ka dahil d naman un ung basehan.

This is probably the last time I’ll comment here. Too tired. :P All I’ve got to say is that Hana Kimi Japan is the best. I’ve watched both (on DVD and CrunchyRoll) and I still like Hana Kimi Japan the best.

To everyone who commented without even watching both shows, just shut up. XP Bwahaha! Merde you all!

xempwe.,!! i’m a CERTIFIED KAPAMILYA.,
sOoo fOr me the BEST ung sa channel 2.,!!

but nO t because i’m a KAPAMILYA it means dun na akO sa mga shOws nila.,!!

kht di me KAPAMILYA i’ll alwaya chOose ung sa taiwan versiOn.,!!

xempwe THE ORIGINAL un d b??

besides mas gustO kO tlga.,!!

Ok a’man ung sa channel 7 but mOre On msa gus2 ku tlga
ung sa ABS-CBN.,!!

THE BEST.,!!

hOpe yOu respect mt OpiniOn like I respect yOurs.,!!

thanks.,!!!

hnd naman porke original ay mas maganda na… mas gusto ko nga yung pag remake ng japan eh… weeee xoxox Ikuta Toma, Shun Oguri. Maki Horikita, Jun Matsumoto, Inoue Mao..

oo nga, nagkataon lang na nauna ang taiwan, pero japan talaga ang orig! title palang kasi… japanese na.. hahahaha

tska ngapla…

proven nb ung sardinas n yn???

4 d min time wg niu idmy yn…

kc wla nmng sardinas n character s hana kimi on both versions…

este meron pla… c wesley…

peace

pero p xencia k!
kse pareho kong pinapanood yan!
pero mas kampi parin ako s hana kimi taiwanese
kasi sa GMA ang arte kailangan pba lagyan nhan
“the newest and the best!” ARTE!
ha!
walang katuturan!
atleast yung nsa ABS- CBN ang nakalagay ay
“THE OROGINAL!”
diba mas ok un kaysa ang nakalagay ay the newest!
MAS MAY KATUTURAN!

AT YANG SI ASHIYA SA JAPAN NMN EH MAS
MUKHANG BABAE KAYSA DUN KAY JOEY – ELLA SA TAIWAN NDE MEDYO HALATA N BABAE EH!

AT KAY SANO NMN AY KUNG IKUKUMPARA MO KAY BRYAN- WUZUN AY MAS GOOD LOOKING XEA AT NDE GAANO MASUNGIT N MASUNGIT AN ROLE! AT ISA P SOBRA N PAYAT NEA!

AT KUNG KAY Nakatsu AT JIRO NMN!
XOREE HA!
PERO KAKAMPI N AKO KAY NAKATSU!
XE MAS MAAYOS XEA UMARTE KAYSA KAY JIRO
XE SI JIRO LGING O EI AT KAHIT SAAN AY O EI
TLGA XEA!
NDE TULAD NI NAKATSU NDE MASYADO O EI AT MUKHANG OGAG!

TSAKA BKT NYO NMAN SINASALI UNG TUNGKOL SA GULO NG RATING NG MAGKABILANG CHANNEL EH DI NMAN UN KASALI SA USAPAN NOH BA KAU ANG GULO NYO! KAYA PTI AQ MAKIKIGULO NA RIN,,,,,,,,,,,,

TSKA NDE NIO NMAN ALM KUNG ANU TLGA ANG ORIG KUNG UNG TAIWAN O JAPAN

MAS GAYA GAYA ANG ABS KAYSA SA GMA
TSKA MAS PINAG UUSAPAN SA SA SCHOOL NMIN ANG HANA KIMI JAPAN NUNG MY PASOK PA KMI
PATI N UNG HANA YORI DANGO

DI HAMAK N MAS MARAMING GWAPO S JAPAN KAYSA SA TAIWAN
TSAKA DI BAGAY SA IMAGE NI BRIAN UNG TATTOO NYA. MAY GUSTO LNG POH AKONG ITANONG MERON BANG ISKUL NA PEDE ANG MAY TATTOO? NAGTATANONG LNG POH…………………….?!,

masyadong o ei ang hana kimi ng taiwan sobrang mg emote

haleeeeerrr clear ba yung eyes nyo it is obvious naman no na mas maganda ang taiwanese version noh ang gwapo ni wu zun at hindi boring di tulad ng isa kaya i really prefer to choose the taiwanese version… Go ELLA And WUZUN nakakakilig cla on screen at off screen sobbraaaa!!!!!!!! see at youtube they relly are comfortable with each other

GMA aq….kay oguri aq!!go deotective conan

@remils17 : HELLO? are you BLIND?
how can you guys be so S T U P I D ? MY GOD.
tinatanong pa ba to ? simple lang yan! hana kimi taiwan fans, you suck! grabe ag sasama nyo! oo alam kong sa pagcomment ng ganito kasi ng sama nyo na rin ako, pero ok lang! uso yun e wahahaha

=P
b i t c h e s , hana kimi japan ang ORIG. tenkyu sa mga nagcocomplement sa japan nang walang kamuwang muwang. e p a l kasi kayo e ! nagdedeclare ng sarili nyong orig. W H A T E V E R. kasi japan naman tlga a ng orig noh! sadyang b o b o lang tlga kayo kung di nyo alam na taiwan ang totoong copycats
brutal ba? belat! naiinis na tlga ako e. ilang araw na kong napipikon sa mga comments nyo!

@ tenma : edit ko lang yung comment mo ah? thanks! XD

~ mas maganda kya ung sa hana kimi ng japan hindi nyo pa kasi nasusubukang panoorin at isa pa manga kya ung hana kimi eh,ang manga galing japan

TSKA OVER SA PAG EMOTE UNG C JOEY SA HANA KIMI NG TAIWAN, ISA PA MUKA XANG BABOY! HINDI TLGA SILA SILA BAGAY NI BRIAN
TSKA DI RN DAPAT ISALI SA USAPAN KUNG ORIG O BAGO {dahil HK japan naman ang tinutukoy nyang dlwang adjectives na yan}
TSAKA DI CUTE UNG MGA CLASSMATE NILA JOEY D KATULAD SA HANA KIMI SA JAPAN MY MGA CUTE DUN .. not to mention GWAPO tlga

ISA PA KAYA Q RIN NASABING MAGANDA UNG SA JAPAN DAHIL NAPANOOD Q NA NG BUO UN SA CRUNCHYROLL.

try nyo? baka sakaling gumaling yang cataract nyo. LOSERS :P

part 1:

all hail the great japan ! and to others there, join hands with me and let us spread the japanese love ♥

oh yeah. i know i’m b r u t a l but who cares! nye nye !

nga pla, everything’s so perfect in the japanese version

super bagay ni Oguri Shun ang athlete image nya kahit hindi xa gwapo dun {tgnan nlng natin xa sa HANA YORI, k? haha }
yeah. mas gwapo yung counterpart nya pero .. athletic ba xa kung tgnan? hell no!

Si Maki naman, super perfect din nya. di naman tlga kelngan ng masculine look {it was more of a pig look if you ask me} para sa Mizuki role nya e . she isnt supposed to be a man kasi babae naman tlga xa. at sabihin nyo nga, pano naman maiinlove yung dalawang guy kung tipong ella ang ipapartner sa kanila. my god. P A T A W A !
at yung sa counterpart ni nakatsu, hay, O A . ampanget ng pagka-O A. di tlga ako natatawa. umamin na kayo, halos lahat naman tayo dito e nalibang kay nakatsu, he’s the best ever! kaya naman the best talaga ang JP version
ang gwapo pa nya. grabe. super perfect ever tlga!

Ang astig astig ni Shun Oguri… chaka yung about kay Ashiya Mizuki na halatang babae.. bakit, wala bang lalakeng cute?

@ nicole ~ meron. di ko naalalang sinabi kong wala.

di pa kasi ako tapos sa pagcomment e. naman.

GRABE bakit naman ganito dito! ilang oras na ah. di pa rin ako makapasok. nako naman.

oh siya. hindi ko na alam kung pano ko imamagic eh

tata for now!

basta mas maganda ung hana kimi japanese version! OA ng girl dun s hana kimi ng ABS.. mukang ewan! mas cute c mizuki.. original ung s GMA kc nga “hana kimi” nga ung title.. duh?! sasabihin nila original ung taiwanese pero ung title is obviously japanese!! DUH!!!!

wlang kwenta ang hana kimi ng ABS… anu nman un?! pumunta lang ung girl dun pra mag pa cute lng d 2lad kay ashiya na may purpose ang pagpunta nia dun!!!!!

bakayarou!!! bakayarou lahat ng nagsasabi original ung hana kimi ng ABS!!! BAKA! BAKA!!

mas gusto k talaga ung sa japan version n hana kimi

GMA ‘s japan hana kimi version is the best……….,,,,

wait lang guys, andami ng nadamay ^^”

BASTA SAKIN, NAASAR AKO SA ABS NA YAN DAHIL SA “THE ORIGINAL” WHATEVER NILA. HAY.

anyway, wow. i sure didnt expect THIS many, but i sure am happy ♥
waaaa pero im so sure, madami na naman mangbabash. oh well. bring it on!

Long Live Hana Kimi JAPAN!

WAHAHAHAHAHA RIGHT ON! totally agreed!

HANA KIMI:JAPANESE VERSION!!! LOVE IT……..

those who loved hana kimi9japanese version)…wooohhh!! were the best…..

hey!!! you better stop it nah!!! we can see naman which is the best eh!!! dito samin sa marawi kahit walang ratings ABS-CBN really excels than GMA7,therefore hana kimi taiwan rules!!! hehehee!!! kapamilya kami dito, walang nanunuod sa GMA7 kasi lahat boring!!! owww… ang cute ni ella chen at wu zhun!!! pangit so sa 7!!!! masakit aki!!!

ang ganda ng hana kimi japanese version noh…… ang gwapo kaya ni nakatsu shuichi (ikuta toma)

to daal:

as i said “IF” and im not expecting….

to japanese hemi:

wu zun is cute and i also knew him before hana kimi taiwan because of romantic princess wherein hes much cuter…..and mind me although the mangga is from japan the original one is still taiwan..if taiwan wouldnt make a hit then theres know reason why japan wouldnt make their adaptation…after all its there mangga…they depend on taiwan!!thats my point!!
and the time hana kimi aiwan was aired on japan it garnered much rating rather than japans versions!!does this mean that japanese people muc love taiwans version than their own adaptation??yes because firstly taiwanese version has a much meaningful,funnier, version rather than japan wherein the series is serious…

thanks to all that supports wu zun liang shi han(senior nan),jiro wang and ella chen…pls continue supporting them mainly wu zun and its group fahrenheit

to mor2:

i love hana kimi taiwan but arnt you just watching it because its from abs-cbn???what if it was aired on gma??would you even care to watch the series??

to all pipzz out there pls stop saying you love the series just because its from your favorite network after all this site needs true pipol to give true opinions and this doesnt discuss on which series is aired on which network you love and youll just love it because its from the network you love

it doesnt matter kung mas magaling magdub ang abs-cbn. the point here is, hana kimi japan is better than hana kimi taiwan. i’ve seen one episode in the taiwan version, mas maganda pa rin talaga yung japanese. nakakadistract yung pagmumukha (oops sori) nung girl sa taiwan version. ashiya mizuka is prettier. and the guys in hanakimi japan are really hot especially ikuta toma (nakatsu shuichi). there is no doubt talaga na magaling gumawa ng mangaserye ang Japan, proof na jan ang Gokusen at hanayori dango.

basta para xken maganda ang hana kimi taiwan wala aq pakelam sa 2 network at pede ba walang craan ng network kc parehas cla nagpapasaya sa mga tao tama na away noh sa mga walang kwenta bagay!!

peace na tau lahat ok!!

~to mariel:

re:don’t doubt a person(demon) by its demonic aura
this for julianne the disgraceful past
just tune in GMA and U’ll know
for mariel this is the right way of using KNOW!

to mariel: iba po ang MANGGA sa MANGA!!! in english, MANGGA is different from MANGA! ~duh!! in case u dont understand.. :)

jiRo?! u mean the one who looks like BAKA there?! yuck!!!!!!!!!!!!
hana kimi taiwanese version sucks!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

hana kimi taiwan.. so disgusting!!!

chaka ng mga cast.. belat!! ^_^

to maldiitah_017: galing m magsalita… maganda ka ba?!

taMA nd panget c ella chen cgeh nga pagharapin ko kau dlwa baka mapanganga kau!!

wala pulaan manood na lang kau!!!

. ohh?? gLet kna niAn?
.. reLax gurL..

nde tau cheAp..

nkkpAg away kha dhiL
lan d2 sAa hana kiimi??

ahahax.. :))

babaw aa..

wak guEnun,..

patay na patay kha nMn maxhasd0o sAa hana kiimi [japan]

haha :)

weL mei muka akhu’
mEi il0ng..

mEi mata..
mEi bibig..

haxhax.. :))

miining..

. ♥ mAgAnda♥ .

oi??
d akhu nag mmyabang aa..

tntn0ng mhu khu ee..

cnsg0t lan phu kiitah..

ahaha :))

Luv iit..

yuck.. mukang baboy c ella chen…

t0: julianne

i Love u!

jowK lang tuwa nman xhia….

oo bka time ka nah panget?

:: t0o pretty juLLiNnE
♥ ngexx?? ahaha :))
♥ xiEmpre c0nsider nha un nhu..
mEi ta0 ba nMng wuLang tEnga..

ngeex.. :))
haxhahx.. :))

pahiya akhu dun khitt k0ntee aa..

wahaxhx.. :))

. admiit itt.. x)
biingi kxe akhu ee..

ahAxhax.. :))

sArA is mAh naEm..

Luv iit.. :))

.

for me… i prefer Hana Kimi on ABS… ang cute ng lead male actor nila noh! yipeeeeeeee! ganun kc ang mga tipo kong guy! hehehe!

ay naku grabe.. kahit mapuyat ako eh watch pa din ako ng hana kimi… i work during the night kya kahit oras ng tulog ko pa yung 4:30 eh gumigising tlga ako para lang dun!

wla sa itsura yun pare!!!!!!! chaka nman ng taiwan version!! OA.. lalo na ung ella chen.. ~yuck! (and in case u dont know OA, its over acting meeen!!!)

i know what OA means…. i respect other people’s opinion so if you hate Hana Kimi Taiwan ver that’s fine with me… i am not forcing other people to want what i want..

MUCHU!!! ahokaonaiwa!!!!

t0 juLianne::
♥ kaw aa?? xhad0o mhung cneseri0x0h mga t0piic d2..

ee dih dun kna sAa hana kimi japan mhu..

n0 nid 2 arguE gurL..

bAstha akhu..

nggandahan akhu saa haNa kimi[taiwan]

..aun.. wahahaxxx :))

..lanang pake eLamanan..

ok? aryt..

muAshZx.. :))

paus0o kna man xhad0o juLiannE..

haxhax .:))

pEacE.. :))

*to malditah:

pikon ka na ba?!

ikaw ung seryoso jan e.. uumm.. ingat-ingat!

careful..

puso baka malaglag!!!*

malditah: ..well, ganun tlaga ang buhay!! gaya ka gus2 mo?! ngaun m lang ba nirinig yan?!

hoy bakit ayaw nyo sumagot

basta wlang krapatang sbihin ng abs na orig cla!

to xyra.. excuse me?! singit ka?! well, wla akong gnagwa sau ha?! bigla k lang lumitaw jan.. :)

to julianne

bket? nttae k na?

amp-phanget mhu pLa….mhuka kng isda…hehe…

woh tlaga nkita m na ko?!

singit singit k lang jan eh!!!

galing m naman!!! wooohhhh!!!!

meron k bang supernatural powers?!

o? sagot pa?!

wla ng tao??

heehhehhheheheh……………… ang saya saya nmn bsahin lht yan.. may nag aaway may nag cocorrect.. napunta ang usapan sa mga kapangitan ng netwroks.. tsk tsk tsk wag nyo namang ibuko..

para skin opinion ko lng mas mganda ung TAIWANESE VERSION mas nag eenjoy ako panoorin ska kc mgaling ung dubbing ng abs prng tama lang ska pala tama ung nasa taas cute kasi ung mga bida lalo na si wu chun ,even thou okey ung japanese kesa same lng nman ng story yan ang nagkaiba lng is ung char some scene saka ung dubbing ng station d ko type ung dubbing mas feel ko pa panoorin ung dvd na may english translation kesa ung sa gma inaantok ako. Hindi ko pinili ang nasa abs bcuz im kapamilya even thou 22o kapamilya ako but i also watch SOME shows in gma . This is just an opinion so sa mga gma fanatic wag kau mag react ng pagkaoaoa u can post also ur opinion naman eh.

sana mapalabas na din sa abs ung romantic princess ska Tokyo juliet ill will w8 it talaga

bzta mganda ang storya ng dalawang version… cnusubaybayan ku nga ung dalawang palabas kc mganda pa dun eh.. iba ng oras …
,,,
……………kaso nung tumagal..naguluhan ako..kaya focus lang me sa isa eh mas feel ko kpag gwapo ang lalaki.. eh KAPAMILYA nalang me… peo!

UNG mga nagsasabi na KAWAWA ANG KAPUSO? ..ok lang un EH SA KANILA UNG RATINGS NLA EH….

ung nagsasabi ng KAWAWA ANG KAPAMILYA? .. ok lang un bzta proud clang NUMBER ONe ang KAPUSO! ….HEHEHEHEH….

add nyu nalang me sa friendster roxanney_13@yahoo.com

for celyn…

sorry ha.. kaya nga po binigyan nang website para sa mga nag dedebate..eh sisingit mu nmn yang lover nature mo… pleas lang iba kc ang pinaguusapan d2..

ang buhay tlga pag may tulad na TAONG JULIANNE eh matatae ka tlga sa mga nassabi nya….

pazaway ka nmn ice un nga ung tinutukoy ko… makalaglag panty tlga ung sa abs.heehhe

ay pacencia naman roxan… i know naman n sya sinasabi mo eh..nbasa ko naman ung mga comments mo//heheh

eh c JULIANNE? MUKANG TAE YAN! tingnan mu ung mga comment nya sa taas …naku!!!!!!!!!!!! eh para tlga xiang PIMPLE na sarap tirisin…hehehe

hayyyyyyy….

hay…. kakaantok

PEACE

hay naku!!! ala naman cnabi ang gma kapus eh lipat na kau sa abs
kung sa hna kimi tlg mas mganda ang story ng abs
kaya mga kapus wag lang umasa sa sardinas amoy isda na kau!!!!!!

alam nio ba ang mga nanunuod nang tawainese version ay mga taong walang taste and obssess….. DUH…..

GRABE MANIRA UNG gma fans… natutunan nila yan sa gma mismo… tsktsk…

bkit ksi may ganoong station?? sinisira nila ang magandang image ng pilipino…

di naman kasi ABS-CBN at GMA ang labanan dito eh, kundi JP Version vs Taiwan Version… hahayz.. basta mas maganda ang JP

Sa totoo lng I both watch d’ 2 networks..,I see prng mas mgnda yta yung JAP.ver. ng HANAKIMI kac mas bgo yun e..,tyka,npnood q n yung taiwan ver.eh..!mgnda nmn pro..,mas maganda ang Jap.ver. kac nga bgo!!!! :)HA..HA..!

cguro, taga Luzon kayong lahat d2 noh?.. kc aq taga mindanao.. hana kimi twn vs. hana kimi jap?! pra sa amin. yung taiwanese version na napapaganda pa ng quality dubbing ng abs-cbn.. Abs-Cbn vs Gma?. total, napag.uusapan din lng nman, hindi ho Pilipinas ang Manila, Luzon, Visayas, Mindanao, yun ang Pilipinas!.. kaya, yung ngsasabing no.1 ang gma, taga manila cgurado yun.. kc. dito sa Mindanao, kakaunti lng ang nkakakilala ng gma.. pati din po sa visayas, sabi ng pinsan q na taga cebu.. kc, ang mga shows ng gma, wlang kabuhay2, parang iisa lng ang artista at hindi professional yung mga host.. tsk. yan lng ho.. salamat..Ü

buti pa i concentrate niyo ang topic sa hana kimi japan vs hana kimi taiwan, kesa sa abs-cbn vs gma- wala akong paki sa mga networks, basta mas maganda ang japanese version

bakit di kayo makasagod time na ba kayo

magkasabwat kayo poljan at che no

ansya pla makipag away sa internet hahaha

puro sagutan lng wlng suntukan

hahaha

mas enjoy kc less harm

:: hAiZxt.. mhuxtha nMn??
:: cnHu gus2ng mkpAg usAp xkEn?? ::
ahahax :))

sAa gurL lan aa..

wuLang ePaL..

haha x)

sArA is mAh nAeM..

:))

hi malditaH

HEY!! gaNda talaga ng Hana kimi taiwan,,,

SV ng iba ang ganda daw ang hana kimi japan pero mas feel ko ung kilig sa Hana kimi taiwan promise…

I will explain kong bakit sa tengen ng iba mas maganda ang hana kimi japan sa taiwan
kc ang hana kimi taiwan ay ginawa nung 2006 at ang sa japan ay nung 2007
xiempreh nabago na ng japan ang lahat ng hindi maganda scene sa taiwan dahil nga nuuna ang taiwan

iIF!! kung nauna ang japan sa taiwan sana mas maganda ang sa taiwan sa japan

getZZ nioH,,,

roxan girl and that maldita one. whatever kayo. kayo nga jan ang hot eh. oa pa kung makapagcomment. yes, i mentioned your names na para derecho kagad. ang ganda di ba?

at yang closemindedness na yan, u l u l , wala kayog karapatan magsabi nyan. lahat naman dito e ganyan. and that is because we stick to the idea of “everyone is entitled to their own opinion”
kawawa nman si julianne ba yun? hayaan mo! itataguyod ko ang japanese version!

and nga pla, ONCE AGAIN, THIS ISNT ABOUT ABS-CBN VS. GMA .. OO! HINDI TLGA ITO TUNGKOL JAN! yung mga e-e p a l e p a l jan na nagsasabing di maiiwasan yun, well, magisip naman muna kayo. sisingit singit kayo jan e sa hindi nga ito tungkol dun. nako naman. YUN LANG YUN!

i AM a kapamilya, seriously. at gaya nga ng sinabi ng halos lahat, ang ganda ng dubbing nila, ever. at super trained ang talents nila. but who cares?

if i know yung mga ayaw papigil na obsessed fans ni wu .. something, ewan ko pangalan nya, i m pretty sure e di nyo naman pinanood ang japanese version.

di kanga sure…. maraming nag cecare ng dubbing d mu lang alam…

kaya nga sana eh pnuorin nalang nila sa net. that way, they’ll appreciate more of nakatsu. haha. yeah, obsessed fan din ako! kaso nga lang, ni toma. oh, who cares. hahaha

nd nmn kc para sayo un.. para kay jerbell… haaaaaaaayyyyyyyy……..(///_

hay. yan lang pla ang masasabi mo eh .. ? naman.

anung gusto mong sbhin ko….? kaw anu nmn ang masasabi mo?

ok…

boring ba?…uhm… eh type mo ba ung started with a kiss?… tanung ko lang ha..

kaw guzto u rin ba ung started with a kiss?

ok………. daming cnb.. ok…

hmmmmmmmm…..(///_^)

paghilum mo ui.. dugay na kaau na nga issue…

agREE aqowh sa lahat ng nagsv maganda ang taiwan version
Nd kasali ung dalwa network kundi ung 2 version,,,ng hana kimi

to emina
basahin mo na lang comment q ulet tinatamad ako magtype

hi roXan!!

sa mga taga GMA:

eH LoSERzz naman pala kau!

bakit hindi niyo matanggap na mas magaling talaga and abs-cbn?at ang hana kimi sa abs-cbn?! eh, xerox copy naman talaga `yang gma na `yan at sa subrahan ng ka-desperado `yan namigay pa ng sardinas!

hana kimi-japan V.S hana kimi-taiwan

ORIGINAL-taiwan
(kung original ang sa japan bakit hindi sila nag-defend sa sinabi ng taga abs? ang sinabi lang kasi nila ang the best sila! pero tingnan niyo parang binubogbog na sila…hahahah)

DUBBING-taiwan
(well, we all know that)

CAST(boys)-taiwan
(obvious naman dba? pangiit ang nasa GMA hahahah totoo naman ha!)

CAST(girl)- taiwan
(maganda ang japan kaso ang nasa script magpanggap na lalaki -eh walang silbe ang kanyang kagandahan-)

PHOTOS-taiwan
(ang serioso ng mga pics sa japan -comedy ang hana kimi remember)

COMEDY-taiwan
(O.A japan O.A … hahah wawa)

To carolLe:

>>On originality: Both of the station’s placing the phrases “The Orig” and “The Newest and the Best” are desperate attempts on their parts to get people to watch their shows. If you think about it, both are adaptations of the Japanese manga and thus ARE NOT TOTALLY ORIGINAL. Also, both of the versions centered on two different themes and thus, you can’t compare them based on originality.

SCORE: Me = 1, You = 0

>>On dubbing: Are we talking about the ABS-CBN and GMA dubbing? Have you watched the original versions (and I mean both)? Then you can’t comment on dubbing because you have no comparison because you don’t know how they should really sound. Also, do you even watch both versions on TV? If you don’t, then you really can’t compare. At least I’ve watched both and know how they should sound.

SCORE: Me = 2, You = 0

>>On the Cast (Guys):
The number of cute guys on Hana Kimi Taiwan = 8
The number of cute guys on Hana Kimi Japan (those I know by name) = 11
I think everyone just thinks Wu Zun is hot (I know he’s hot! I’m not blind.) and thus thinks everyone in Hana Kimi Japan is not cute/hot/handsome/gorgeous.

SCORE: Me = 3, You = 0

>>On the Cast (Girl): I’m amazed! I didn’t know you read the script! But seriously. As you said, the “script” (I really should say manga) asks for a girl pretending to be a guy. Who said that a girl pretending to be a guy can’t look like a girl? The whole point of Nakatsu’s character liking Ashiya’s character is because she’s too “bishounen” (I’ll use that term even though she’s a girl). Ella, though in real life is cute, her character in Hana Kimi wasn’t too cute. I mean, she looks too butch and not bishounen. If you want, read the manga. The manga says that Ashiya is bishounen and even in the manga, she looks more like a girl than a guy.

SCORE: Me = 4, You = 0

>>On photos: Have you seen every Hana Kimi Japan photo and every Hana Kimi Taiwan photo? How can you comment on the seriousness of the photos? And come on! Hana Kimi is still technically a drama (I mean a TV show drama) and doesn’t that mean that you can have “serious” photos?

SCORE: Me = 5, You = 0

>>On comedy: Hana Kimi Japan is OA? Seriously? Then what do you call Ella’s facial expressions? That’s OA. Do you know anyone who actually looks like that when thinking? I don’t think so. And what’s OA about Hana Kimi Japan comedy? It’s a comedy! It’s like saying Jiro (Xiu Yi/Wesley) is OA when technically he isn’t. I mean, lots of people see him as OA but I don’t think so because it’s what the manga asks for. And I found that Hana Kimi Taiwan was more serious than Hana Kimi Japan. In Hana Kimi Japan, immediately after a serious scene, a comedic one followed. Hana Kimi Taiwan had lots of serious scenes.

SCORE: Me = 6, You = 0

Ha! How sad. You lost. You can’t combat logic.

@ roxan ~ oh. ngaun ko lng nabasa ung comment mo na hindi para sakin yun.
haha. pero .. err .. narealize ko rin naman kani kanina lng nung nagbabasa ako , kaya .. ok na? i guess so.

Hana Kimi JP is better.

Hana Kimi in Taiwan is really better. I would just say that, the Japanese version’s ending is better. However, the Taiwan version makes more sense and the chronology is properly executed; moreover, some revelations in the Japanese version is not “revealed” the right way. Or should I say, the revelations in the Taiwan version is simply better.? At the end of the day, the quality of these dramas are dependent on the judgment of their viewers.

hmmmmmmmm nako napaka ganda ng Hana kimi taiwan kay sa sa hana kimi japan. kasi ang hana kimi japan ay parang joke only. at alam nyo ba na ang mas original na gumawa ng move ay ang taiwan. ahmp gayagaya lang ang japan Don’t you know that. ahmp mag search nga yung mga ipinag sasabi na mas original ang hana kimi japan. pls Don’t talk firts pag di nyo po alam.

di nyo ba alam na ang nagpapangap na lalaki sa hana kimi japan ay mukang babae. at ang sa hana kimi taiwan naman ay mukang lalaki. at napaka cute kahit di masyaduuung maganda. paano ba nakapasok sa all-boys school yung girl sa hana kimi japan o diba ipaliwanag nyo nga parang nag buuuuubuuuulahan lang sila.

kaya sa all na gusto sa hana kimi taiwan ay may babalita ako sa inyo jejejejejejje may hana kimi taiwan 2 na ejjejejejejej.

@kharaski20: hindi mo ba alam na mas maganda sana kung nagbabasa ka ng mga prev comments? paulit ulit naman kayo kung magbring up ng pngdebate

@lalaki ako : im SO sure, di mo na nga mappnuod. imposibleng may makapagconvince sayo pag ganyan. hahahaha.

manga -based???E, d k nmn cgro mrnng mg-bsa ng manga e,pro Jap.words lng nandun e…,ha..ha..!prng gsto n yung Hana Kimi Taiwan.ah!prng konti lng kac yung nag-susuport sa show n yun e..,pro magaling sila mag-dub ah..!(yung Abs-cbn)… FOR:SILENTWILLOW…

ang pangit nga ng pag dub nila eh parang nagpipilit na parang natatae he he he !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!buti pa yung gma parang totoong boses ng artista atsaka for your info pinalabas ng gma ang meteor garden due to public demand at gusto ng mga people sa gma ipalabas dahil mas magaling silang mag dub and actually ang ganda ng isang drama ay hindi mo makikita sa pag da dub kundi sa ganda ng mukha ng mga actress and actors and it’s so obvious that the artist in hana kimi japan are more fashionable, hansome, beautiful and most of all they know how to act well that they even got the best actress, best supporting and best drama e sa hana kimi fake ng abs meron????????????????????? wala kaya it’s not sikat ha! ha! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! WA WA NAMAN WAG MUNA KAYONG UMIYAK KC MAGMUMUKA KAYONG MONKEY OR LOBO ha!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

naku!! ang original ay my origin! dUHH san nkuha ng TAIWAN ANG hana KIMI? EDI sa japan!! BA-KA NE!! fooLS EI ANO NMN KUNG ORIGINAL!! eh d nmn D BEST! halata nmn a title EHH! “HANA kimi” JAPANESE WOrd un! so DONT TELL na orig yang sa kapamilyuCKS!!

hana kimi – japan is the best….. Horikita Maki is one of the best japanese actress

Hana Kimi Japan.
yung sa Taiwan kc, parang ginawa lang live-action yung manga, and spiced a bit. and namaaaan, though yung reason Lu Rei Xi is based from the manga, hindi pa rin xa ganun ka-”acceptable” (for me), so i go for Ashiya Mizuki. plus, ang saya saya ng plot wit Hibari Four and the other added characters na wala naman talaga dun dapat.

Ashiya Mizuki/Lu Rei Xi :: Horikita Maki/Ella Chen
~ ilang best actress/best supporting actress awards na ba ang nakuha ni Maki? i-google niyo. haha. from Nobuta wo Produce to Kurosagi, Maki’s the best. i lurve her so. Sorry Ella, mas okay ka as a singer in S.H.E.
Verdict: Horikita Maki. Hana Kimi Japan.

ahahah GMA7 ROcks! sna HUWAG mangaya ANG abs cbn NG MANGA SERYE huh!! mGA DAKilang gaya-gaya KXE EII….

BASTA GWAPO SI SANO SA HANA YORI!!! AHAHAHA TAE YANG WU ZUN NA YANG! MUKANG TOILET NA FLINUSH!!
SI ELLA PRNG BABOY NA PINAKAKAIN SA FARM??! AHAHA LOLS

the jap one is better because of the pace of the story and the of course the story itself….
the jap offers a lot of unique and funny scenes….i just cant help laughing..
thejap characters are way more handsome than the taiwanese
the taiwanese is good too because of wu chun i guess..LOLS

SUCKS HKT!! FEELing anG TAAS ng ratings?? AHAHA feelingeras! SO kawaii NAKATSU!!

alaM KO nmng NANONOOD kau ng HKJ! admIT?? insecure LNG kau!! MGA kapamilyuCKS tlga!

clap,clap,clap!

gling manira ng ESTATION! khit SILA aNG TLGNG target!
see 4 urselF NLNG!! mga DKILANG “gaya-gaya”…

nku MAY pbb P PLA kaung CNASABI jan! NKU!
yan lng BAH itatapat u sa GMA7?? haiizzz,,,

BKA pag TINAPAT yan ng ibang shows sa gma BKA malugi eii!! wawa nmn

HANA KIMI JAPAN SO KAWAII!! I PREFER ASHIYA MIZUKI,MAKI HORIKITA(BEST ACTRESS)

ELLA CHEN(BEST PIGGY actress)

WOOOO

NAKU JAN PLANG ATA SA “HIBARI 4″..

TALO NA YANG PIGGY PIGGY ELLA NIO EII!!!
nakatsu more kawaii KESA JAN SA ISA PNG BIDA NG TAI!!
CNU BA UN?? d ko kilala eh
sorie sa lhat ng pnuntahan kong 4rum!! puro HANA KIMI JAPAN SILA EH!!

ahahaha

wawawa!!

i lyk hana kimi JP bcoz,, MGNDA AT MGALING ANG MGA cast!!
NDEH TULAD NG Orig DAW!,,prng IMPOSIBLE MNGYARI SA REALITY AHAHAHA!!

Hahahahhahaha review ba to? Anyway Wow! ang saya ! Pareho silang kumuha ng Hana Kimi at sabay pa ng showing ha! MARCH 24 pareho!

Di naman sila masyadong nagcocompete. haha

Hana Kimi Japan

-Mas natuwa ako sa acting ni Horikita Maki (syempre fan nia ako). Though nasanay ako na ang kateam nia ay si Yamapi (na crush ko), I think okay din naman ang naging tambalan nila ni Oguri Shun

-Gusto ko kasi di Exag acting ni Horikita sa role. Cute cute cute! :)

-Mas maganda ang ending ng HKJ kesa sa HKT (spoiler muchieS?). Sana magumpisa na ang Hana Kimi 2

- ANG BENTA !!!! hahhaha

to ChE ChE bUrEcHE:

Oh my.. May nawawala ata ah :) Don’t you know that manga’s are being translated in english. Nagsasalita hindi naman tama. Poor you. Madali lang maghanap ng manga’s translated in english. Hanap ka lang sa any bookstore.

to kharaski20:

Once again, may hindi nagbabasa ng mga previous comments. Where did manga’s come from? JAPAN. How can you say that taiwan is original? And them(abs) putting ‘original’ is an desperate attempt for viewers to watch their show. You know the story of Hana Kimi right? A GIRL trying to look like a boy. They have lines na sinasabi ‘Ba’t may lalaki mukhang babae dito?’ The girl still needs to look like a girl. And read Daal’s comment. The girl needs to look like a bishounen. Don’t talk first whatever. HAHA. Your just making people laugh.

mas maganda ang japan!!

hello!!!

try nyo kyang mgbsa ng ibang mga forums nd’ f ur desperate to defend hk taiwan
lhat n ng mga forums n hana kimi tai vs. hana kimi jp eh bsahin nyo n!!

but in the end mkkta nyu lng s srili nyo n ms gusto ng majority around d WORLD

ung hana kimi japan!!

cmon!!

bket meron vah kaung award?!!

* 54th Television Drama Academy Awards: Best Drama
* 54th Television Drama Academy Awards: Best Actress – Horikita Maki
* 54th Television Drama Academy Awards: Best Supporting Actor – Ikuta Toma

i just post it s mga mkktid and utak

at halatang pagka palengkera lng ang pnaiiral

hay maganda pa rin hana kimi ng 2

i luv the “nakatsu shuechi” of japanese versoin coz he’s hotttttttttt!!!!!!!!!but i luv also the “izumi sano” of taiwanese(s my spelling correct?)he’s more handsome.

hay nku! iPAGPILITAN BNG MAS MGNDA SA 2!!

E2 HUH, SSBHIN KO NA!! LHAT NG TAO(NDEH PLA LHAT DHIL MRMI ANG SUMASAMBA SA HANA KIMI TAI)EH MAS PREFERRED SA “japaN version”..

cOME 2 THINK OF IT!!
JAPAN is D most BEAUtiful draMA maker,,AND ITS SO Cool! so WAG MO OR nio sabhin na “O.A” ANG japan,,

EII mas “o.a” pa NGA sa “2″!!

see D DIFFerence NLNg,!!ahaha BKA matawa kau ng grbe sa JAPAN!!AHAHAH..

sa 22o AMPANGET NI Ella! oo nga bgay tlga sknya ang ROLe,,PERO ndeh na ata bumagay hbng 2matagal dhil sa kacornihan!!

RYT??

WU CHUN ba?? OO gwapo xa! PERO ndeh fit s knya ang PGIGING “sano”ahahah..

kala ko more on PGGNG “SERIOUS”?

mas bgay pa rin kay sano!”oguri shun”
ahahah

UN LNG NMN KAYA NIONG IBATO AT SBHIN SA 7! GAYA GAYA,NDEH ORIGINAL,CORNY,O.A!SO WAT EVER!

EII,SAINYOU BNABATO UNG MGA INSULTS NA YAN EH??

NKU LHAT NG 4RUMS SNBI NA ANG CH.2 EH GAYA GAYA
HANA KIMI TAI EHSUPER O.A

AMPANGET! SUPER MRMI PNGA ANG SABI “2ND EPISODE PLNG NG TAIWAN SUKO NA SILA EH”

AHAHAHAHHA

SO BTTEERR WATCH JAPAN V.!

HANA KIMI JP…MORE KAWAII
KYA NGA D BEST EHH

ang pangit talaga ng taiwan kasi si joey laging naka buka ung bunganga ang pamgit talaga ang o ey!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! siyem kapuso naman ako:::::::::::::::::::::::::::

wahahaha..
kagwapo lng sa hana kimi sa abs-cbn duh..
pataka r jud m noh..

how pathetic. naging endorser na lahat dito ah

@kharaski20 : kaya lang naman nanghuhusga KAMI ng characters kasi rin sa mga kasama mo. ang ep@l kung magcriticize, kala mo naman kung maganda si ella at SOBRANG hot ni wu chun. e mas gwapo pa si Oguri Shun {who plays Sano} pag balik sa Hana Yori Dango looks nya e!

saka .. hindi mo naman pwedeng sbhin na porke naunang gumawa ng move ang tai, japan na ang copycats. wala lng tlgang originality ang taiwan! mga ambisyoso. gusto rn siguro nilang maging japanese : P

hana kimi number!

mukang baboy si ella forevah!

2 Ashiya Mizuki, : BLA..BLA,..BLA!!! d m b alm n ksma si Ellen sa S.H.E? alm m ba yun? Mgnda nga yung girl sa Jap. Ver ng Hna Kimi,pro prang malnorish yta sa payat!!!OK,lets move bck 2 Ellen,sikat kya yung group nila,singer silang tatlo noh!mukhang lalake talaga si Ellen,kya,wag n wag m syang huhusgahan noh..!And by the way,mas gwapo ang heart thrub ng Abs-Cbn n si Brayn noh..!hmp.!

2 Ashiya Mizuki, : BLA..BLA,..BLA!!! d m b alm n ksma si Ellen sa S.H.E? alm m ba yun? Mgnda nga yung girl sa Jap. Ver ng Hna Kimi,pro prang malnorish yta sa payat!!!OK,lets move bck 2 Ellen,sikat kya yung group nila,singer silang tatlo noh!mukhang lalake talaga si Ellen,kya,wag n wag m syang huhusgahan noh..!And by the way,mas gwapo ang heart thrub ng Abs-Cbn n si Brayn noh..!hmp.!

to che che bureche:

TLGA SIKAT ANG S.H.E?? WELL D KO SILA KILALA EH!! SO DONT TELL NA SIKAT SLA DHIL NASA PILIPINAS TAU!!
SKA NDEH PINAGUUSAPAN D2 ANG S.H.E OKEI!!AHAHA

UTAK NMN! ANU ANO PA KSE PNAGSASABI!!
TRY 2 WATCH 1ZT JAPAN! LALO NA EPISODE 11,GRBE SUPER COMEDY,UNLYK SA INYOU MATATAWA KA SA “KAKORNIHAN” DBA??LOLS

AMININ NA KXE EII!! AHAHA

To kharaski20:
Ok. Obviously, you don’t read past comments. As I’ve already said, the character of Ashiya/Rui Xi is supposed to look like a girl pretending to be a guy. Just because a girl is pretending to be a guy doesn’t mean she can’t look like a girl. The whole point of Nakatsu/Xiu Yi’s character liking Ashiya/Rui Xi is because she looks so much like a girl and thus finds himself liking her even though he believes she’s a boy.

Btw, what’s jejejejjejeje? No one understands your alien language.

To ChE ChE bUrEcHE:
I wasn’t aware someone couldn’t know how to read Japanese. I’m sorry. And, has your brain rotted away? There are so many translated mangas available on the internet and in bookstores. Have you heard of Tokyopop? They’re the main manga tranlators and distributors worldwide. You can find Tokyopop mangas in National Bookstore, Powerbooks, and Fully Booked to name a few. Also, search on the internet! You can find scanlated mangas on the internet.

Btw, it’s Ella and not Ellen. If you’re going to comment on Ella, at least get her name right. Secondly, not everyone knows S.H.E.

To taiwanese:
I wasn’t aware Japan wasn’t allowed to make live action dramas out of mangas that came from their own country. It’s like if someone made a comic here in the Philippines and America made a series out of it and the Philippines made their own a year later. You can’t say that the Philippines are copycats right?

To ashiya addicts:
I agree. It’s not like ABS-CBN owns Wu Zun.

To everyone who says the Japan people are too thin and looks malnourished, it’s their culture. Their society dictates that thin people are beautiful or handsome. It’s like in the Philippines. Our society dictates that busty and buff guys are beautiful and handsome. But not everyone feels that way.

Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej
Hana Kimi Taiwan is #1 sa lahat and the best period jejejejejejej

Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period
Kapamilya is #1 sa lahat period

Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period
Kapuso is sucks and comakapi lang sa kapamilya period

yan ang isipin nyo

blablablaaaa,ang cnasabi q khit san mapunta ang hana kimi taiwan un parin ang magugustuhan ko opinyon ko un d ko cnabi na isa ung fact intindihin mo nga mabuti…….. ay naku BEST ACTRESS kaya yang si Ella kung o.a. yan d yan mananalo d lng ito haka-haka totoo i2………bahala nga kau bsta maganda ung hana kimi taiwan……….

buti pa maging botohan nalang ito, hana kimi taiwan vs hana kimi japan, ako kasi mas gusto ko yung japan, yun lang.

I love Hana Kimi Japan and i am aware that others love the Tai version , but if you (all of the fans) dont want me to continue bashing your idols, then stop first saying stup!d things

and btw, i didnt know a group S.H.E. existed until you mentioned it on your comments so, i dont know they are THAT popular. maybe in Taiwan and for you, Taiwanese fans, but definitely not here.

and yeah, there is no use to bring up the network rivalry again here since neither ABSCBN nor GMA really made that tai nor the jap version .. so yeah, dont bash the jap version just bec it’s being aired by GMA7

[supposedly part one]
@nicolo: oo nga, wish ko nga lang Poll nalang ito para magkaalaman na.

@C h E Ch E bUrEcHE:
quote//bka nmn mas maganda pa nga sya s u eh..!BAB0Y KA,EMINA..!//
~ owwwws. “b@ka” lang naman yan

i know that was harsh but i just cant stand what the others have to say, which are just as harsh as what i’ve said
as everybody else’s line states, that is only my opinion
there are far more negative comments that they throw at japan right now, so i dont care what you’ll say about me. i know myself.

dami nman nagalit sa cnbi ko
ahhhhh!!!!

ok
ok

preho na love ko ang dalwang show!!!!
understood u na ha????

hana kimi tai:

c ella chubby nga!
good actres at singer pa!
c wu chun gnun din at gwapo katulad ko
heheheheh!!
c jiro “kalog” at astig naman no!!!

hana kimi japan:

c ashiya ay super cute at ang gnda tlga
best actres pa!
c sano gnun din!! good actor!!
dami ko na napanood yun smula gukosen at hanayori1 at 2!!gling
c ikuta toma!!un da best!
versatile na actor sya!!!!!

o!
bsta da best ung
story ng show!!

galing!!!

hahaha,,,..

wula nng maibato ung tai!!

pnu vah yn?!!

hehehe

nnggugulo lng!!

mas maganda ung hana kimi Taiwan, mas nagmumukhang lalaki si Reixi, at mas maganda ang pagkaka act nya..mas cute then ang guy sa taiwan keysa sa japan

i lyk the taiwanese version,guyz this isn’t a network war, ok?kapamilya ako but i know there are somethings na mas maganda sa japanese version kaya lang mas gusto ko yung original kasi mas realistic.

I love both versions. It’s just that I like Hana Kimi Japan more. That’s all. Go Hana Kimi Japan!

To Che Che BURECHE..: ikw yta yung pinaka talo kong mag-type e..,ha..ha..!nakakahiya ka..!anu..?wla kng reply..?ha..ha..ha..!ELLEN daw..!ELLA.!TANDAAN MO YAN..,IDOL MO PA NMN YUN..!HA.HA…!PAHIYA..!!!!

Mas gusto ko yung Hana Kimi ng ABS CBN kasi mas nakakatawa yung character at nakakatuwa. Yung sa chanel 7 kasi seryoso masyado. In fairness mas mukha talagang lalake si Joey ng Hana Kimi ng ABS na nakakapagpadagdag ng kakulitan at nakakakilig pa kasi ang cute ng leading man… At I agree sa maraming nagsasabi dito na basta dubbing ang pinag-uusapan number 1 ang ABS CBN diyan, da best. Almost yung mga shows ng ABS excellent ang pagkakagawa at quality, mula sa kwento, concept, production at sa acting. LIke their very worthy show na ASAP at Maala-ala mo Kaya.. hindi mo masasabing basta basta lang yung ginawa nila kasi pinaghahandaan at pinag-iisipang maigi. At siyempre yung acting napakaganda kasi winoworkshop pa sila bago simulan ang isang project. At ang mga Statiion ID panalo talaga pang world class ang ganda pa palagi ng theme nila. Di tulad ng iba wala man lang kadating dating… ABS CBN KAPAMILYA TALAGA NUMBER ONE!!!

nkkatwa cla!! i don’t care nmn s mga network blues n yn eh

hoi kng mg search p kyo ang sbi nga nila ms nauna ang taiwan version eh nging skat n skat s jpan kya gumawa rn cla un ung hana kimi japan kya goooo goooooo hana kimi taiwan

ejjeje maynalalaman pa ang Gma dahil kinuha pa nila si paquio jejej di ko alam ang spelling ng name nya but kinuha nila yan di nman sya magaling sA pag host at mag drama jejejeje think about it parang nagbubulahan lang sila.

ang topic ko ay wala sa hana kimi but isipin nyo ang sinulat ko

ABS-CBN is the best pa rin and the original and they give high quality of drama,show,etc…..

maganda ang hana kimi taiwan kasi nakakatawa yung gina act ng girl character at kahit di sya masyadong maganda di nman ginabasi sa pagpapagandahan yan eh sa pag arte yan diba.

BULAG KA BA O MALABO ANG YONG MATA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

icnlin lng ung taiwan name s english name……………………..
wala nmn tlgang cnb ang cast ng Hana kimi ng GMA s cast ng Hana kimi ng ABS-CBN

kung saan lng yt pinulot ang cast ng Hana Kimi japan, d nga yt pnaghandaan ang show ng Hana Kimi japan

s tabi2x lng yt cl npulot ang cast ng Hana Kimi japan ………………………………………….

To Baby Humps:cno k b..,pra manghusga ha..!tyaka emina,i know n its just your own opinion..,so,kng opinion nga yun,opinion q rin yun noh..!n “bka”k???sori kng mali yung “ellen” kac tao lng aq..!TAMAAN SANA KYO NG KIDLAT..!

Iam bck!!!

MORE POWER SA HANA KIMI JAP..!

olow po!!… agree p ako ky mik mik 22o puh ung mga cnulat nia try nio nlang pong mgresirh tngkol poh jan pra mlaman nio kung anu poh ung d best

skn lng poh ay hana kimi japan is dabest!!!!!!…….

thank u poh

mas maganda tlga ang hana kimi japan!!!!!!!……^_^

Btw, in response to the person who says that the Hana Kimi Japan cast can’t act, I’d like the say that I feel like the Hana Kimi Japan cast acts more naturally than the Hana Kimi Taiwan cast. Especially Ella who I think looks stiff while acting as Rui Xi. That’s all. I forgot to include it in the last post. ^_^

d nga nakkexcite yung Hana Kimi s Taiwan e,kac nga mas nauuna yung Jap. ver. so,prng may konting parehas s both 2 country show,so,kng napanood n yung s Jap. Ver.,s gabi,alm n kng anung mangyayari bks s Show ng Tai Ver….

over react si daal hahaahhaha totoo siguro ang lahat ng sinabi namin wajejejejejejej.

@Baby Humps- nauna po ginawa ang taiwan version ng hana kimi.

Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink Toink

just w8 for the ratings to show jejejejeje ay di nalang ratings jejejej baka mandaya naman ang Gma.

YEAH………………………..
I’VE watch it it’s OK but the characters don’t act well at mas gugto ko ung pagkakasunodsunod ng story,at mas nakakakilig at nakakatawa pa
THE BEST TLGA ANG HANA KIMI TAIWAN……………….

BASTA PARA SKIN !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

NO.1 ANG
HANA KIMI……………………………………………
………………………….TAIWAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

HANA KIMI JP FTW!

and w8 a minute. I forgot many thing to say. ejjejeejej still Hana Kimi Taiwan is the best and funniest in acting and to all who judge Ella its docent matter if she is not good looking right it’s not a reason that hana kimi Taiwan is bad. why if you watch a move or a drama you only watch the face of the beautiful/handsome characters and byetheway i want you to know that in the beach part of the Japanese version is sucks.

still the hana kimi Taiwan is the best 4ever jejeje.

ahh..k,i respect your own opinion toink…,but is that manga books who is the fist one produced..?so..,by the way,I love the Jap. Ver. because it is very funny and the characters there are very energetic…so,I like that Jap. ver..!sya nga pla Che Che Bureche,peace n tyo ha…?!na search q n nga yung S.H.E n cncbi n Che Che Bureche e..,d q nmn kilala yung dlwang yun e,cna Selina and Helina b yun..?Corney kac ng name e.!ha..ha..ha.!he…!!!!

NKU DPAT SA ATING LHAT! HANA KIMI PILIPINO VER.!!

NIYAHHAHA

GE BEST REGARDS NLNG SA DALAWANG CHANNEL!!

MAS TYPE KO PA DIN ANG JP!! LALO NA SA BEACH!!NYAHAHAH

dpat hndi n tyo mg away away kc wla nman tyong mppla at tyaka iba iba ang taste ntin pro ang opinyon k lng ms mraming gwapo s taiwan si bryan weslie at si tristan sper gwapo un lng peace out

pls. lng mag-produce p kyo ng mas nakktawang Jap. drama ha..!i like that HANA KIMI FOREVER..!!!!!!(D’ BOTH NETWORKS..)PROMISE,I SWEAR..!!!!!!!!

pero sa hana kimi taiwan pa rin ako

To toink:
It’s not an overreaction. Just because my post is long means that it’s an overreaction. At least my posts have depth and reason. If you’ll look at all my posts, I’ve expounded on all that I’ve wanted to say and that’s why they’re long. I don’t write a comment which has no content. And if I found what you all said to be true, do you think I would’ve been able to write such a lengthy comment?

By the way, if you’re going to talk in English just to try and outdo me, don’t do it. You’re just going to embarrass yourself.

Another thing, the beach episode of Hana Kimi Japan was one of the funniest episodes in the show (and that’s a wonder since I think that all the episodes have their share of funny moments). And I agree with blablablaaaa. The statement “the Japanese version is so very boring and corny” is not a fact but an opinion. I don’t say, “Hana Kimi Taiwan is not funny and boring, and that’s a fact” because it’s not. It’s an opinion. It’s not even my opinion. I just like the Japanese version because the Taiwanese version had a number of dragging parts.

To lol:
Thank you! It’s also been annoying me that some people here can’t write decent comments. You know, comments which state their preference without bashing the other show. Others write over exaggerated things about the show they don’t like that’s not even true.

To emina:
Thank you for your comment. I live to make people bleed. Haha! Just kidding. XP Oh! And by the way, I’m a girl. ^_^

To blablablaaaa:
I agree. I think a lot of Hana Kimi Taiwan lovers just prefer the Taiwanese version because of Wu Zun. And what’s sad is that most of them don’t even like Wu Zun because he’s a great actor but only because he’s handsome. They might say that they like him for his acting but I really believe a number of them only like him for his looks and that’s just insulting to Wu Zun. I mean, I prefer that Hana Kimi Japan version but I do like Wu Zun too. Not only is he handsome, but I like the fact that he’s multi-talented. He can act, sing, dance, model, play basketball, box, and a lot more.

To everyone who still brings originality to the picture, please refer to the second paragraph of my post dated “April 8th, 2008 at 5:46 pm”. I’ve already discussed there how both shows can be considered original. And if you comment with how the Taiwanese version was the first to be shown so that makes the Japanese version a copycat, please refer to the same paragraph I’ve stated above.

That’s all for now. ^_^

by the way,how old are you n,Daal?Ang gling m kac magsalita e..ha..ha..Idol!

To Baby Humps:
I’m 22. ^_^

To VYULYTE :
Have you watched the original versions? Actually, GMA did a better job at dubbing. If you’re going to bash me as a GMA supporter, let me tell you that I’m not. So don’t even start.

To Daal: are watching abs cbn’s Hana Kimi Tai ver?even you are a supporter of the JP?And ano ang sinosoport m..?abs or gma?

I HATE YOU ALL..!!!!!PEACE..?WHATS PEACE??PEACE YOUR FACE,BABY HUMPS…BASTA,LOVE Q PRN YUNG TAIWAN VERSION NG HANA KIMI..!NOH…!WLNG PAGSISISI!!!THATS ALL..!SYA NGA PLA,I2 N LST COMMENT Q..

daal ok lang yun eh bata pa naman ako ikaw matanda na ejjejejejje bebebebebebe hahahaha nasaktan ka siguro sa sinabi kawawa naman don’t cry na ha jejejejejeje

@Daal : Wow. a girl! Ang galiiiiiiiiiing. Idol na rin kita ! :D

Grabe. Ang iba talaga dito e pikon. Masaya na nga ako kanina kasi may nagkakalma na sa place e tapos si che che bureche whatever e biglang isip bata. Sige, pagpatuloy mo yan, jan ka lang, solohin mo Hana Kimi Tai Version mo. Hmph!

How childish. You’re SO pathetic you know that? Wala ka na sigurong mabato. May kapareho ka dito e, whatever, tinatamad na kong tgnan yung pangalan. anyway, kung yn nlng ang mababato mo, okay go on,

to Toink: huyy…!alalahanin m,toink,mli spelling m..!still d “steal”..!tlgang bta k nga…!d p msyadong memorize yung mga spellings..!TOINK..TOINK..TOINK..!????WHAT SO EVAH…!MAY PA GANUN GANUN K P HA..?!PIGGY PIGGY..!HA..HA..HE..HE..!SORI KNG IAM SO BRUTAL AND MALDITAH..!IAM THE ONE WHO IS VERY RESPONSIBLE ON CHECKING SPELLINGS HERE..!JOKE!!! WAG MAPIPIKON..!

qng pangit c sano,, pangit nmn c ella!!

hehe oa nmn nun

cute c ella

maganda c horikita maki!! (ashiya)

ska bachoy n tlga ung pgmmukha ni ella!!,

emina hmmmmmm jejejejje kumain pa ako eh jejejej sa chowking toink toink toink

ayaw ko nga mag one on one kasi busy ako parati eh ahmp kasi nag summer job pa ako hmmmmmmmmmmm

at may idagdag pa pala ako madaling mapikun ang mga tao dito tsk tsk tsk
hahahahaha

its a war hmp jejejejej joke lang toink kung magalit ka totoo na pikun ka

okie “Wer nicht die GroBe mauer bestegen hat, der ist kein rechter kerl”
“Ein Hohepunkt jeder Chinareise ist ein Bereich der GroBen Mauer” okie
hangang dito nalang muna ha kasi tinutulungan ko pa mom ko toink babu
see you later nalang jan 2peace

I really like the hana kimi Taiwan very much :D

I’m pretty sure the ones you posted here which are stated in other languages were probably copied and pasted from .. wherever
LOL.
I think that latest one is in kanji but of course, I may be wrong. I still don’t know whatever it’s in. So, mind translating them for us?

Ahhh .. i think it’s in Taiwanese [I just remembered that the Chinese writing kinda resembles the japanese one and since Taiwan is practically under China, more or less .. that's the lyrics for a HK Tai Soundtrack. Is that right?]

hmmm..i love hana kimi JAPANESE version! very funny tlaga.. hahahhaha.. XD nka base tlaga xa sa original na story ng hana kimi which is in the manga. anime na anime tlaga ang dating! weeee!!! at yung mga cast nila mga GWAPO lhat!!!!! at PRETTY also..hehe.. unlike nang hana kimi taiwanese version…hmm..di ko kasi feel ung girl dun! hehe..mas cute pa si Ashiya! ^_^ hehhee..

-bsta JAPANESE VERSION the best! =] Nakatsu ang pinaka favorite ko don! ang cute2x! hehehe.. *drooling

…wawawaaaaaWWWWWWWW…….. ang pagbabalik… haaaaaaayyyyyy…. tgal kong nagpahinga….. sa tgal na yun… ang dami nang nag away.. tsk tsk tsk.. pero EMINA sangkot ka sa lht ng away…heheheheheheh oh tapos aku nmn titirahin mo? ok….
…………..
………………………. sasak mo sa baga mo ang jap ver. mo! heheheheheh un lang..,,

to: kharaski20

hehhhehe…….. tnx nga pala sa MAGANDANG BALITA!

oh? ikaw ang pinaka cuteeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee sa lht emina!

san kana emina? …haaaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy yan ka nanman na wawala…

anu un?

kamuka pala.. sorry tao lang…

^ yups? Calling for me? O, baket?

anu ung may SOMETHING?

Zomg. Dapat ba talaga natin gawing chatroom to? Nako naman.
Just one more thing .. uh .. Roxan?

roxan to ang sagut ko: c mike tan

i don’t want to say something now hmmmmmmmm kasi may ibabato naman sa akin si emina but emina whats wrong with jejejjejeje hmmmmmmmmmmmmm I’m very interested hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm wag nanga ako mag ejjejeje hmmmmmmmmmm nalang sige forgot what i wrote nalang I would like to say peace on earth guys toink hahahahehehehehohohohuhuhuhuhu pasyensya na kayo dahil isip bata ako toink :( sige Good night na sa inyung lahat and sweet dreams have a happy pupu tomorrow :D :D :D go hana kimi Philippines and Taiwan your the best toink

may takot ka kay emina?.tsk tsk tsk…

hehehe .. Waaaaa SO sorry, toink! Cge, pashensha kung pinambato ko pa sayo
At salamat.

ayaw kasi mapost kanina e kaya eto.
Sorry.
Basta, Yun na yun.
Roxan? Nanjan ka pa pala? Inaadd kita sa ym ah? May sasabihin sana ako.
Oh well.

Hmm .. Sana nga may Filipino version na tayo ! Tsk tsk.
Im keeping my hopes up! : D

HAY NAK!!!! you were all fighting just because of that it’s non sense it’s not a big deal!

ANOH GUSTO NYO RAMBOL NA LANG!!??

JOKEZ!!!!!

GO BRIAN !!!!

CGUO HLATA NAMAN KUNG KNINO AQOH KAMPI!….

HIHI….!!!

sya nga pla roxan,anu b YM m?phingi rin aq!ha..ha..!

ay nako bat di ako maka post hmmmmmmmmmmmm

correct ka jan sharlene :D

Oh mY gOsH,,, taiwan version is much better than japanese version…
taiwan is more funnier than japanese version
and the characters did well compare to the other version…
the japanese version is so boring…
why dont you try to watch hana kimi taiwan
before you saying anything bad….
all you have to do is just face the reality…
hana kimi taiwan is much better….
so just watch,, and we’ll see…

first of all we’re not talking about the stations..we’re talking about the series..in my opinion hana kimi JAPAN is really really better compared to the taiwanese version..because hana kimi JAPAN is more realistic and it has many many values..not like taiwanese version..in terms of originality..JAPAN is the winner because duh?! it’s a manga series..even though taiwan did it first..in terms of the actors..yes, the lead actor in hana kimi taiwan is handsome compared to sano..but the supporting actor of the japanese version(nakatsu) is more more handsome than the supporting and lead actors in the taiwanese version…right????!..in terms of the actress..ashiya is a lot lot lot lot lot better that ella..i’m sorry but it’s true..ella is like a guy that makes him like a gay because she’s a girl..we must be realistic..if you are pretending to be a boy you must not look like a real boy because you’re a girl..and in terms of the acting..japanese version acts realistic not like in taiwan that acts really really over.
HANA KIMI JAPAN forever.!!!!!!!!!!!

Oh. Nasobrahan ako sa pag-expect. kala ko babahain na to ng comments e.

Sige, napadaan lang.
Japanese version for me
And rochelle, i’ve watched the tai version already, and i know im not the only japanese ver – lover in here

Ja ~

hay nako salamat may tao na dito hmp kanina ako lang isa ngayun marami na toink toink

hana kimi taiwan is the best hohohohohohohohoho

basta mas maganda ang JP version.. ang baduy ng TAI version! taiwan version sucks…

IF HANA KIMI TAIWAN SUCKS,

HANA KIMI JAAAAAAAAAAPAN
SUCKS MORE…………………………!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ANG HANA KIMI TAIWAN AY BINASE SA ISANG JAPANESE MANGA AT SINUNOD NTO ANG PAGKAKAAYOS AYON SA MANGA IF TAIWAN VER SUCKS …..MEANING UNG JAPAN MANGA UNG SUCKS KC GINAWA LNG NMANG MAKATOTOHANAN UNG NASA MANGA AT LA MASYADONG INIBA

ISIP-ISIP NGA MGA PEOPLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

correct ka jan taiwanese toink hana kimi 2 is the best among the rest

yeAh!!! emErald, i agree with u!!! it is real that hana kimi ABS-CBN is the best! the characters are very very great!!! wu zun is…Oh my gOsh!!! he’S veRy hAndsOme!!!!! anD jOey,,, anD wEsLey!!!! aaaahhhh!!!!! oh mY gOsh!!!! i reAlly rEalLy lOve iT!!!! compAred tO hAna kimI jApanese verion, HELLO!!! wElL, iT iS ur dEciSion! and i believe that all oF uS hAve our own tastes!!!

THAT’S ALL!!!!

emerald vandergeld,trixie,plinky correct kayo hahahahhaha wala talagang matatalo sa hana kimi 2 the best talaga 4ever hahahahaahaa

YeZZzzzz!!!!!
HANA KIMI TAIWAN GO,
WALANG KWENTA ANG NAGSASABI NA
MAGANDA ANG HANA KIMI JAPAN,,
HEHEHEHE!!
NATUTUWA AKO KASI
SA ABS NAPUNTA NAG HIGH-CLASS
NA VERSION,,
WUUUUUUU,, BELAT NYO!!!!!!!!

FOR DAAL AND EMINA
hay naku, tanggapin nyo nalang kasi, mas maganda
ang hana kimi taiwan…
tama nga ung iba dyan
nakakawa kayo…..

……hey you!!!!!!maz cute si joey n don s hana kimi THE ORIGINAL NOH…ATSKA NAZ GWAPO LEADING MAN NIA DON!!!!!SI BRIAN!!!!!!!WHAHAHA….WLANG BINABAT UNG ODERZ NOH!!!!!!!OOOOOOOPPPPPZZZZZ…….BATO BATO S LANGIT TAMAAN WG MGLIT!!!!!!HAHAHAHAHAHAH

Uhhh .. Naemphasize lng naman ung sa Language dati kasi biglang may nageenglish para lng magpaimpress .. ?
But .. no biggie.

If you’re a Taiwanese fan, then, go, kayanin niyo yan! Pagpilitan niyo pa ha?

Hay. I was born for japan, and so , ill go for japan
I like the idea of the Japanese ver, wherein the supporting actor seemed to have outdone the supposedly lead. Sayang at hindi sila in the end. But .. i just lavet it as it is <3

If you’re a Taiwanese fan, then, go, kayanin niyo yan! Pagpilitan niyo pa ha?

Hay. I was born for japan, and so , ill go for japan
I like the idea of the Japanese ver, wherein the supporting actor seemed to have outdone the supposedly lead. Sayang at hindi sila in the end. But .. i just lavet it as it is <3

Halata naman na hindi marunong mag high jump yung pambato niyo!Hindi pa nakakakilig acting ba tawag dyan?!!

HOY DAAAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLLL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

D KA BA NANONOSE BLEED??????!!!!!!!!!!!1

pano mo naman nasabi na born ka 4 Japan?HA!

HANA KIMI TAIWANESE VERSION! ANG PANGIT!!!!! TSK3… HOW SAD.. :(

hmmmmmm sounds parang may away hehehehehehe joke lang peace on earth toink toink

SUPER NO. 111 ANG ABS-CBN
1111 111111 11 11
11 11 11 11 ERSION
11 11 11
11 11AIWANESE
111111 11

BYE BYE!

kaya pangit ng ending ng hana kimi taiwan kasi may part 2 pa yun okie hehehe

ang ganda ganda talaga ng “hana kimi taiwan” its my favorite Taiwanese Drama talaga pero kung sa Japanese nnaman “Nabuta wo produce” and paburito ko ehheheheh the best 4ever ang hana kimi Taiwan hehehehehe

@Toink: Waaaa sori naman sa double post! Ayaw kasi lumabas kanina e. Senxa naman ^^” Cge. Peace, toink :D

Hay. Cge. Bahala na.

ano na japan version

duwag na mga ppol!

.. buti pa hir dami fans ng abs
d2 hauz loner ako!!!
.. well khit ganun,, daig prin cla
skin!.. lah cla mgawa,
mga amuy sardinas clang
lhat!!! nway to all fanatic
2 abs,, let us prove we
are the WINNER ABS RULES!!!
GMA SUCKS!!!

@kaPamiLyA FOREVER! :
Awww .. The memories.. Parang nakikita ko ata sarili ko sayo. hahaha.
Ang sama mo. Pero xempre, parang sinasabi ko na rin na masamo ako pero totoo naman kaya .. Ok.
Nanunuod naman talaga ako ng Taiwan. Yun lang.

@ivanah: LOL. Magandang rason yn, prang ang sama natin XDDD
Anyway, nope , hindi talaga pareho ang storyline. Ang plot siguro pareho pa [tama ba ko?]
pero magkaiba talaga sila. Yun lang!

to rochelle:
Ang funny mo! Haha! Pinipilit mo kami? Pinipilit ka ba namin? Ba’t ba ayaw mo tanggapin na mas gusto namin ang Hana Kimi Japan? Aww.. Kawawa ka naman.

to kaPamiLyA FOREVER!:
Napanuod ko na both versions. And by the way, ba’t mo sinama yung channels? Tell me if you even use your mind, Saan galing ang Fahrenheit and SHE? Sa TAIWAN diba? So, ba’t feeling niyo, pag-aari ng ABS sila? Tskk.

to HK Taiwan:
Walang ginagawa si Daal sa’yo, at inaaway mo siya? So what if your not only bilingual? Does it mean you can speak fluently in english? Haha.

Anyways, Ang bulag niyo. No offense. Ba’t ba hindi niyo makita na maganda naman yung both versions? I like Hana Kimi Taiwan and I don’t say anything bad about it. And I really like Hana Kimi Japan. Ano ba paki niyo kung anong version gusto ko? Just accept na hindi lahat ng tao, gusto yung gusto niyo. How pathetic.

Of Course i CAN SPEAK FLUENTLY IN ENGLISH WHAT I WAS TRYING TO IMPLY IS THAT I CAN SPEAK OTHER LANGUAGE BESIDES ENGLISH

DO YOU THINK A GIRL CAN STUDY IN A BOYS SCHOOL IF SHE LOOK LIKE A GIRL SO THE SHOW REALLY NEEDS SOMEONE WHO WOULD LOOK LIKE A GUY, A GIRL PRETENDING TO BE A GUY SHOULD LOOK LIKE A GUY CAUSE SHE’S PRETENDING RIGHT????HOW COULD SHE PRETEND TO BE A GUY IF HER IS A GIRL …………..OH………PLS………. THINK CAREFULLY……….. ASHIYA LOOK LIKE A GIRL IT’S NOT LIKE SHE’S PRETENDING TO BE A GUY AND DETERMINED TO SEE SANO HIGH JUMPED

hoy GIRL..as in hey DAAL!!

mgcocoment k na nga lng..mali pa yung PLURAL form..hahaha!!!
CRUSHIES daw.. alam q kc CRUSHES db?? hehe..

sounds like merong fight dito hmmmmmmmmmmmm tsk…tsk…tsk.. kay HK TAIWAN nalang ako kasi sa taiwan version sya ejjejje joke lang peace guys toink

hana kimi taiwan is the best 4ever and ever heheheheheheh

HAY NDI NAMAN GIRL YUN EH (jOEY) NDI RIN BOY(JOEY) TOMBOY YUN…WAHAHAHAA!! JAPAN PA DIN

kaya ako ang inyung host na si toink toink toink ehhehehehehe

hana kimi taiwan is the best best best best

quote from kapamilya forever: //hoy GIRL..as in hey DAAL!!

mgcocoment k na nga lng..mali pa yung PLURAL form..hahaha!!!
CRUSHIES daw.. alam q kc CRUSHES db?? hehe..//
^ Nagulat ako dito. Seriously. Haha. Cge, iwan ko nalang kay Daal para sagutin yan at baka sabihan pa kong pakialamera dito

@ toinkmen :
Wow. At talagang dinadagdagan mo pa. Pag-aawayin mo talaga ah?

BAKIT BA? GUSTO KO EH…

blablablaaa:
hay naku, ung hana kimi japan ba ang pinagmamalaki moh??
whahaha!! ikaw kaya ang mas nakakatawa dyan,
bakit ang tanong ko sayo
pinipilit ba kita hah??
sabi ko lang,
tanggapin nyo nalang na mas
maganda ang taiwan version,,
sa susunod read between the lines
AND UNDERSTAND!!!

and also to daal….

in terms of hana kimi versions:
OI s mga fans ng hana kimi JAPAN!…lam nio b meaning ng “ikemen” s ikemen paradise!..nood kau ng nood di niu nmn lam pinapanuod nio…it simply means “handsome guys”..
oo nga gwapo “ibang” lalaki dun lalo na si nakatsu[toma] kso si sano[shun} nmn! my gulay!..kung ikukumpara ky wu chun ng taiwan...cyempre wu chun n!..tp0s nandun p c senior nan[danson] s taiwan!..ang hot!.
OI kung titignan nio…kapag wala sa hana kimi c toma i mean nakatsu!..imagine?..wala na agad buhay ung show..
ee kung s taiwan version kht wla c kim siuyi[jiro] nandun nmn cla ella ska wu chun!..perfect combination!..isng gentle at isng makulit..san kp!..
in other words..HANA KIMI TAIWAN is the BEST!..

s mga taiwanese drama fanatic!..may ISWAK 2 n![it started wd a kiss]
“they kiss again” ang title..

reply kau s comment q kung gus2 nio mapanuod..now n!.

@v0gUe: Xempre naman alam ko ang ang ikemen paradise! in one word: Hottie ang meaning nun. Hottie Paradise, xempre alam ko yun!
For me, hottie naman ang mga cast nila, pero di ko naman kayo pipilitin kng tingin nyo panget si Sano!

At yung kay Ella, di ko idedeny, isa ako sa mga tinutukoy mo, pero .. pinanuod ko pa rin naman.

Wala lang. Yoko mapaka-high blood na e. Mejo nag-iinit na naman dito, baka may mag-away [oh. now i know how it feels to be a referee , an galing! XD]

Solid Japan lover pa ren.

–
Ngaun ko lang naalala:
@kapamilya forever: naalala mo yung tanong mo kng paano ko nasabi na born for japan ako?! Naman! Wag kasi literal naman. Ibig ko sabihin e GANUN ako kasolid sa japan.

Yun lang.
Peace for everyone [wla aqng sinabing harsh ngaun!]

@emina
woi!.
tibay mo chong. gcng kp?.
haha. wla qng cnabing panget c sano.
di q lng cia type.